Sputum smear negative pulmonary tuberculosis: sensitivity and specificity of diagnostic algorithm
© Swai et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2011
Received: 14 March 2011
Accepted: 1 November 2011
Published: 1 November 2011
The diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis in patients with Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) is complicated by the increased presence of sputum smear negative tuberculosis. Diagnosis of smear negative pulmonary tuberculosis is made by an algorithm recommended by the National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Programme that uses symptoms, signs and laboratory results.
The objective of this study is to determine the sensitivity and specificity of the tuberculosis treatment algorithm used for the diagnosis of sputum smear negative pulmonary tuberculosis.
A cross-section study with prospective enrollment of patients was conducted in Dar-es-Salaam Tanzania. For patients with sputum smear negative, sputum was sent for culture. All consenting recruited patients were counseled and tested for HIV. Patients were evaluated using the National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Programme guidelines and those fulfilling the criteria of having active pulmonary tuberculosis were started on anti tuberculosis therapy. Remaining patients were provided appropriate therapy. A chest X-ray, mantoux test, and Full Blood Picture were done for each patient. The sensitivity and specificity of the recommended algorithm was calculated. Predictors of sputum culture positive were determined using multivariate analysis.
During the study, 467 subjects were enrolled. Of those, 318 (68.1%) were HIV positive, 127 (27.2%) had sputum culture positive for Mycobacteria Tuberculosis, of whom 66 (51.9%) were correctly treated with anti-Tuberculosis drugs and 61 (48.1%) were missed and did not get anti-Tuberculosis drugs. Of the 286 subjects with sputum culture negative, 107 (37.4%) were incorrectly treated with anti-Tuberculosis drugs. The diagnostic algorithm for smear negative pulmonary tuberculosis had a sensitivity and specificity of 38.1% and 74.5% respectively. The presence of a dry cough, a high respiratory rate, a low eosinophil count, a mixed type of anaemia and presence of a cavity were found to be predictive of smear negative but culture positive pulmonary tuberculosis.
The current practices of establishing pulmonary tuberculosis diagnosis are not sensitive and specific enough to establish the diagnosis of Acid Fast Bacilli smear negative pulmonary tuberculosis and over treat people with no pulmonary tuberculosis.
KeywordsSputum smear negative Human Immunodeficiency Virus Symptoms
There has been a sharp rise in the incidence of pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) worldwide since the mid 1980's, particularly in the Sub-Saharan African region. This has been attributed mainly to the appearance and wide spread of Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) infection on the continent [1–3]. For the diagnosis of PTB the detection of Acid Fast Bacilli (AFB) in expectorated sputum is still crucial, especially in developing countries of Sub-Saharan Africa, where other facilities including sputum culture for Mycobacterium Tuberculosis (MTB) are unavailable or are prohibitively expensive. When AFB is detected in sputum, the diagnosis of PTB is certain. However diagnostic problem start when patients with suspected PTB have a negative sputum smear . It has always been recognized that a proportion of patients are sputum smear negative using the Ziehl-Nelseen (ZN) stain, the commonly used stain in most laboratories in the region to detect AFB in sputum. This is a simple, rapid and cheap test but lacks sensitivity of a single sputum test . About 5000 bacilli per milliliter of sputum must be present for it to be positive. However it has been reported that multiple sputum tests in a good laboratory can give a sensitivity of about 90% . Sputum smear using ZN stain for AFB seems to be even less sensitive in patients with HIV associated PTB. With the sharp rise of PTB in countries which are worst affected by the HIV epidemics, the number of patients with suspected PTB who are sputum smear negative has increased .
This study was conducted with the aim of assessing the sensitivity of the current recommended algorithm for the diagnosis of sputum smear negative PTB.
A cross-sectional study with prospective enrollment was conducted at Muhimbili National Hospital (MNH), a university teaching and national referral hospital, and at out-patient tuberculosis clinics at the Infectious Disease Clinic (IDC), Mwananyamala, Temeke and Ilala district hospitals, from September 2000 to December 2000. All these hospitals are located in the city of Dar es Salaam. The city accounts for over 26% of all new tuberculosis cases reported each year in Tanzania .
Adult male and female patients aged 18 to 75 years, presenting with chronic cough (≥2 weeks); who were three times sputum smear-negative for AFBs (ZN stain); and who gave a written informed consent to participate in the study and for HIV testing were included into the study. Patients with known tuberculosis or who had PTB in the past, on anti-TB for treatment or prophylaxis; those with known chronic respiratory diseases (e.g. bronchial asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, bronchiectasis), those with misplaed HIV results, contaminated cultue results and those with heart failure were excluded. The study protocol was approved by the MUHAS Ethical Review Committee.
A detailed medical history and physical examination was done by a study clinician and the findings were recorded on a clinical record form. The investigators did not interfere in the treatment of these patients. The treatment centre followed the diagnostic algorithm for smear negative. Laboratory tests included a complete blood count (coulter counter model, manufacturer, city and country) which included estimation of haemoglobin, red blood cell count and indices; and white blood cell count both total and differential. A peripheral blood smear for assessment of red cell morphology was also made. Erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) was set using the Westergren method within 2 hrs of drawing blood.
HIV testing was done according to the Tanzania National AIDS guidelines. Each patient received pre- and post-test counseling and the HIV test was done using a dual ELISA algorithm. Sera which were non-reactive on first ELISA were considered HIV antibody negative, and those reactive on first ELISA were retested by a second ELISA based on a different test principle. Sera reactive on both ELISA tests were considered HIV-positive. Samples with discordant test results were confirmed by Western blot (WB) and western blot interpretation was done according to the WHO criteria .
Patients who came to the clinic with symptoms suggestive of PTB had their sputum examined. Those who were three times smear negative were consequently selected and asked to bring one more sputum sample which was sent to the Tuberculosis Reference Laboratory at MNH for AFB culture (Löwenstein-Jensen culture media).
Smears were considered positive if AFBs were seen on smear from any of the three sputum samples. Patients found to have sputum smear positive were treated for tuberculosis according to the National Tuberculosis and Leprosy program treatment guidelines. Those found to have sputum smear negative for AFB and who consented were enrolled into the study. A chest x-ray was ordered for those who were found to be HIV positive. If the chest x-ray results were abnormal, the patient was considered to have sputum smear negative PTB, and started on anti-TB medications. The rest were treated with broad-spectrum antibiotics. All enrolled patients were requested to stay at the clinic for a month for follow up. Two weeks later, patients on broad spectrum antibiotics were evaluated again by doing sputum smear and chest radiograph. Those found to have smear negative sputum but had symptoms still suggestive of PTB were treated as smear negative PTB; others were treated accordingly.
Two weeks later we came back to review treatment of clinician of which others were given ant TB and others were treated for other respiratory problems. Because they followed NTLP diagnostic algorithm, all of them had a chest X-ray done, and all of them were reviewed and reported using a structured format by two independent radiologists. In case of disagreement in their initial independent reporting, they reviewed the radiographs together and resolved the disagreement by consensus.
Sample size and data analyisis
This study was part of another study on that aimed to investigate/examine sputum smear negative but culture positive PTB the association with HIV.
Assuming a sensitivity of 50% and specificity of 75%, a sample of size 413 subjects would give a 95% confidence interval of plus/minus 0.048% for sensitivity and plus/minus 0.042% for specificity. This is a reasonable amount of precision for the given sample size.
Data were analyzed using Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) and EPI Info. Pearson chi-square test was used for comparison of categorical data and a student t-test was used for continuous data. Logistic regression analysis was applied and the direct effects of the predictors were assessed by their 95% confidence intervals. A p-value of < 0.05 was considered to be statistically significant.
Over the course of the study, 467 patients were enrolled. Of those enrolled, 318 (68.1%) were HIV positive. Sputum was culture positive for MTB in 27.2% (127/467) of patients; samples of 11.1% (52/467) patients were reported to have been contaminated. In the remaining 61.7% (288/467) patients sputum was culture negative for MTB at 8 weeks. Of the 467 study subjects, 68.1% (318/467) were HIV positive. Two study subjects whose culture results were negative had their HIV results misplaced. These two, together with the 52 subjects whose culture results were contaminated were excluded from further analysis. Of the 413 samples analyzed, 30.8% (127/413) were MTB culture positive.
Diagnosis made using culture results and Treatment given
(n = 127)
(n = 286)
(n = 413)
Antibiotics without anti-TB
Sensitivity and specificity of the diagnostic procedure of patients with smear negative
Diagnosis made and Treatment given by subjects' sputum culture results and HIV sero-status.
n = 84
n = 43
n = 203
n = 83
Unadjusted bivariate logistic regression analysis of clinical characteristics predictive of smear negative culture positive PTB
Cavity right mid
Cavity other sites
Multivariate analysis of clinical characteristics predictive of smear negative culture positive PTB
This study showed that of those found to have a negative result for AFB, a significant proportion (27.2%) had sputum culture positive for MTB. Therefore our data indicate that smears did not detect PTB in a very large proportion of patients. Sputum culture being the gold standard for the diagnosis of Tuberculosis disease  shows that sputum smear is not a very sensitive tool in the diagnosis of PTB. This has been shown by other studies where sensitivity has been described to be between 51% to 53.3% [10, 11]. One of the reasons for low sensitivity is reported to be due to the fact that 104/ml are required for AFB to be seen using smear microscopy .
Although the gold standard for the diagnosis of Tuberculosis involves the isolation and identification of Mycobacterium Tuberculosis (MTB) using cultures , the cost and facilities of doing cultures are prohibitive in most developing countries. Sputum smear microscopy remains the main diagnostic tool for PTB that allows initiation of treatment and monitoring of patient progress [11, 12]. As sputum smear and microscopy is not a very sensitive tool in the diagnosis of PTB, presumptive diagnosis is usually made based on an algorithm of clinical and radiological criteria. This is commonly termed as AFB negative PTB [9, 13]. In some cases when sputum smears are negative but the patient has clinical features highly suggestive of PTB, broad-spectrum antibiotics are recommended for at lest 10-14 days and sputum smears repeated. If the patient's condition does not improve while sputum smear remains negative, a chest radiograph is done and if found to be abnormal, a presumptive diagnosis of PTB is made and the patient is started on anti-Tuberculosis treatment as AFB negative PTB . In this study patients whose sputum smears were AFB negative, were evaluated using the above algorithm by the treating doctors at the clinics or hospital. A presumptive diagnosis of AFB sputum smear negative PTB was made in 41.8% (173) of all study subjects, and patients were started on anti-TB treatment as recommended by the Tanzania NTLP. The remaining 58.2% (240) patients were assumed to have other forms of respiratory diseases and were treated accordingly.
Less than half (38.1%) of those who were presumed to have active TB and started on Anti TB actually had TB by sputum culture results. More than 60% of these patients they received 8-months of treatment despite having a negative culture results. This is similar to what has been reported before in Malawi were it was reproted that 40% of smear negative had TB confirmed microbiologically after taking Broncho alveolar larvage . The treatment of individuals without tuberculosis adds to the cost of the TB programs in most developing countries. Likewise about 48% (61) of patients who had active tuberculosis by the results of sputum culture were missed and they received inappropriate treatment, leaving them vulnerable to developing severe disease as well as remaining source of TB infection in the community.
The current diagnostic algorithm leading to the establishment of the diagnosis of AFB smear negative PTB is inefficient; it over-diagnoses PTB and misses a lot of people with active disease. Instituting a more sensitive diagnostic tool will prevent the unnecessary cost of treating individuals who do not have TB and at the same time it will prevent the further spread of TB. This emphasizes the need of culture and the need of further research in order to identify a better diagnostic tool for diagnosis of AFB negative PTB.
In an attempt to improve on the diagnostic algorithm, the study looked at the clinical presentation of the patients to identify clinical laboratory and radiological features that are associated with smer negative PTB and which can be used to predict PTB in patients with symptoms suggestive of PTB. A multivariate analysis showed the following features to be highly predictive of AFB negative but culture positive PTB; low eosinophil counts, a mixed type of anaemia and the presence of cavities on chest radiographs. Low eosinphil seems to be an incidental finding Further studies have to be done to confirm this findings
Limitation in the current study is the inclusion of patients with cough of more than two weeks in which there may be inclusion of patients with simple chest infection that sometime may be complicated with cough for 2-3 weeks. This may be a selection bias that may explain the low sensitivity and specificity of the diagnostic algorithm.
Another limitation is the method of sputum delivery, which is delivered by the patient himself, may have affected the results as some might bring saliva.
We could not be certain that the algorithm was followed at all times because resechers were not involved in the management of these patients rather we evaluated the treatment gien to patients by the attending clinicians. In Tanzania National TB and Leprosy programme is well organized and the algorithm is well adhered by the District TB and Leprosy Coordinators and all workers of the NTLP who were the attending clinicians in this study
• The current procedures of establishing AFB negative PTB are not sensitive enough to establish the diagnosis of active tuberculosis. They under-diagnose PTB and over treat people without PTB.
• The presence of a dry cough, a high respiratory rate, a low eosinophil count, a mixed type of anaemia and presence of a cavity were found to be predictive of smear negative but culture positive PTB.
The study protocol was approved by the MNH Ethical Review Committee.
Written consent was obtained. To those who were not able to write oral consent was obtained
The strength of our study is that it evaluates very well the dignostic algorithm.
1. We do not recommend adhering to the diagnostic algorithm.
2. A much more sensitive diagnostic algorithm for smear negative pulmonary tuberculosis should be developed to be able to identify those individuals who are actually sputum culture positive for AFB.
List of Abbreviations
Human Immunodeficiency Virus
Acid Fast bacilli
Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Mycobacterium Tuberculosis
National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Proagramme
Infectious Disease Clinic
Muhimbili National Hospital
World Health Organization
Enzyme Immunosorbent assay
Statistical Package for Social Sciences
The study was supported by the Muhimbili University of Health and allied Sciences. We wish to thank Dr Kazema and Dr Kimaro (X-ray and imaging specialists) who read all the X-rays. We thank and Mr Ngowi and Mr Shogolo (Laboratory technicians) for storing and working on the sputum samples. I thank doctors who assisted in data collection and last but not list I wish to thank Dr Makwaya (Biostatician) for assisting in sample size calculation and data analysis.
- Colebunders RL, Ryder RW, Nzilambi N, Dikilu K, Willame JC, Kabito M, et al: HIV infection in patients with tuberculosis in Kinshasa, Zaire. Am Rev Respir Dis. 1989, 139: 1082-1085.PubMedView Article
- Elliot AM, Luo N: Impact of HIV infection in Zambia A cross sectional study. BMJ. 1990, 301: 412-415. 10.1136/bmj.301.6749.412.View Article
- Timpe A, Runyon EH: The relationship of "atypical" acid-fast bacteria to human disease: A preliminary report. J Lab Clin Med. 1954, 44: 202-PubMed
- Barker A: Sputum amear negative PTB. Tropical Doctor. 1993, 23: 145-146.
- World Health Organization Geneva. TB Control as an Integral part of primary health care. 1988, 11-
- Manual of the National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Programme in Tanzania fifth edition. 2006
- Donald A, Murray Earson John: Global epidemiology of Tuberculosis. Tuberculosis. Edited by: William N Rom, Stuart M Garay. 1996, Brown and company, first
- Millar JG: On the spread and prevention of tuberculosis disease in Pond land, South Africa. BMJ. 1908, 1: 380-383. 10.1136/bmj.1.2459.380.PubMed CentralView Article
- Treatment of Tuberculosis guidelines for National Programmes. 1997, World Health Organization
- Vignesh Ramachandran, Balakrishnan Pachamuthu, Shankar Muthu Esaki, Murugavel Gangatharan Kailapuri, Hanas Settu, Cecelia Jebaraj Anitha, Solomon Suniti, Kumarasamy Nagalingeswaran: Value of single acid-fast bacilli sputum smears in the diagnosis of tuberculosis in HIV-positive subjects. J Med Microbiol. 56 (2007): 1709-1710.
- Cattamanchi Adithya, Dowdy David, Davis J Lucian, Worodria William, Yoo Samuel, Joloba Moses, Matovu John, Philip Hopewell, Huang Laurence: Sensitivity of direct versus concentrated sputum smear microscopy in HIV-infected patients suspected of having pulmonary tuberculosis. BMC Infectious Diseases. 2009, 9: 53-10.1186/1471-2334-9-53. 1471-2334-9-53PubMedPubMed CentralView Article
- Harries AD, Maher D: TB/HIV A clinical manual. 1996, World Health Organization, 20-
- Manual of the National Tuberculosis and leprosy programme in Tanzania. 2006, 22-Fifth
- Hargreaves NJ, Harries AD, kemp JR, kwanjana JH, Salaniponi FM: Smear -negative pulmonary tuberculosis: defining better approaches to case finding and care in Malawi. Review article in Malawi medical journal.
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.