Skip to main content

Table 2 Change in HRQoL scores from baseline to 12 weeks, mean (SD) unless otherwise stated

From: Health-related quality of life in a trial of acupuncture, sham acupuncture and conventional treatment for chronic sinusitis

 

Change score

Mean difference between change scores

 

(1) Acupuncture

(2) Sham

(3) Conventional

(1) – (2)

(95%CI)

p3

(3) – (2)

(95%CI)

p3

(3) – (1)

(95%CI)

p3

n

15–18

14–16

16–17

         

Chronic sinusitis survey 1

            

Sinusitis symptoms

11 (23)

8 (24)

32 (41)

3

(-24 to 31)

0.96

24

(-3 to 51)

0.09

24

(-3 to 52)

0.14

Medication effects

-0.5 (18)

8 (22)

-10 (21)

-9

(-26 to 9)

0.44

  

*

  

*

Total

6 (15)

7 (18)

10 (24)

-1

(-19 to 17)

0.99

  

*

  

*

Short Form 36 2

            

Physical functioning

1 (16)

0.5 (13)

6 (17)

1

(-12 to 14)

0.99

5

(-8 to 18)

0.58

5

(-8 to 17)

0.68

Role – physical

-3 (48)

-12 (39)

28 (36)

9

(-44 to 25)

0.8

40

(5 to 75)

0.02

31

(-3 to 65)

0.08

Bodily pain

2 (23)

5 (23)

16 (20)

-3

(-21 to 15)

0.92

11

(-7 to 29)

0.33

14

(-4 to 32)

0.16

General health

2 (22)

-4 (18)

10 (21)

6

(-11 to 23)

0.67

14

(-3 to 31)

0.13

8

(-9 to 25)

0.48

Vitality

-1 (20)

4 (16)

13 (31)

-5

(-25 to 14)

0.8

8

(-11 to 28)

0.56

13

(-6 to 33)

0.21

Social functioning

7 (15)

5 (22)

15 (23)

1

(-15 to 18)

0.98

9

(-8 to 26)

0.4

8

(-9 to 24)

0.5

Role – emotional

-4 (36)

7 (31)

24 (40)

-10

(-41 to 20)

0.69

17

(-14 to 48)

0.4

27

(-2 to 57)

0.08

Mental health

-3 (10)

0 (12)

10 (20)

-3

(-15 to 9)

0.82

10

(-2 to 22)

0.12

13

(1 to 25)

0.03

  1. Change = last value-first value; a negative change score represents reductions in symptoms; * omitted because of medication use in the conventional treatment arm; 1 0 (maximal) to 100 (minimal symptoms/medication use) scale, 2 0 (lowest) to-100 (highest level of functioning) scale; 3 after adjustment for multiple comparisons