Advertisement
Table 4 Measurements for MCT and waiting list comparison group compared before treatment (T1, September 2009), after treatment or equivalent delay for waiting list patients (T2, March 2010) and differences
| T1 (baseline) | T2 (after treatment or waiting list) | T2-T1 differences | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No MCT | MCT | T/p | No MCT | MCT | T/p | No MCT | MCT | T/p | |
| Mac-CAT-T | |||||||||
| Understanding | 4.2(1.3) | 4.7(1.2) | −0.9/>0.3 | 3.6(1.1) | 5.1(0.9) | −3.1/0.008 | −0.5(0.5) | +0.5(0.9) | −3.0/0.009 |
| Reasoning | 5.0(1.9) | 5.5(2.0) | −0.5/>0.5 | 4.1(1.9) | 6.2(1.1) | −2.6/0.023 | −0.9(2.2) | +0.9(2.1) | −1.7/>0.1 |
| Appreciation | 2.5(1.6) | 2.7(1.5) | −0.3/>0.7 | 2.4(1.5) | 2.6(1.5) | −0.4/>0.7 | −0.13(0.9) | −0.1(1.6) | −0.01/>0.9 |
| Total | 11.8(4.3) | 12.9(4.1) | −0.6/>0.5 | 10.3(3.9) | 13.9(2.5) | −2.3/0.041 | −1.5(2.9) | +1.3(3.9) | −1.7/>0.1 |
| Mac-CAT-FP | |||||||||
| Understanding | 9.8(3.8) | 9.8(3.5) | −0.04/>0.9 | 10.6(3.7) | 10.6(2.6) | −0.7/>0.3 | 0.9(2.0) | 2.2(1.7) | −1.5/>0.1 |
| Reasoning | 7.1(1.9) | 7.4(1.6) | −0.3/>0.7 | 5.9(2.1) | 7.8(2.2) | −1.95/>0.05 | −1.3(1.9) | 0.5(1.6) | −1.9/>0.05 |
| Appreciation | 8.3(3.5) | 8.6(2.7) | −0.03/>0.7 | 9.0(2.4) | 9.4(2.7) | −0.3/>0.7 | 0.8(2.7) | 0.7(1.6) | 0.02/>0.9 |
| Total | 23.9(7.5) | 25.5(6.5) | −0.5/>0.6 | 25.1(7.0) | 29.2(7.1) | −1.2/>0.2 | 1.3(5.9) | 3.6(5.1) | −0.9/>0.3 |
| GAF | 54.6(8.7) | 50.6(9.5) | 0.9/>0.3 | 48.0(6.9) | 57.2(9.8) | −2.6/0.021 | −6.6(8.7) | 6.6(12.0) | −2.8/0.012 |
| PANSS | |||||||||
| PANSS positive | 14.0(6.3) | 11.4(3.7) | 1.1/>0.2 | 15.3(5.4) | 13.5(4.4) | 0.8/>0.4 | 1.3(3.9) | 2.2(4.9) | 0.5/>0.6 |
| PANSS negative | 17.5(4.7) | 17.7(6.7) | 0.1/>0.9 | 20.5(4.2) | 16.6(6.5) | 0.6/>0.1 | 3.0(3.8) | −1.1(6.5) | 1.7/>0.1 |
| PANSS general | 27.0(6.6) | 31.7(8.6) | −1.4/>0.2 | 30.0(5.3) | 29.4(10.2) | 0.2/>0.8 | 3.0(4.9) | −2.4(8.3) | 1.8/>0.1 |
| PANSS total | 58.8(14.9) | 60.7(15.2) | −0.3/>0.7 | 66.0(8.3) | 59.5(18.0) | 1.0/>0.3 | 7.3(10.5) | −1.2(18.6) | 1.3/>0.2 |
