Table 2 Content and operationalization of the assessment
ADAPTE | AGREE II | GLIA | AMSTAR | INAHTA-checklist | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Assessment of the medical definitions used in the guideline or systematic review of interest | Assessment of documentation | x | x | x | − | − |
Assessment of content | − | − | − | − | − | |
Complete operationalization* | n. a. | n. a. | n. a. | n. a. | n. a. | |
Assessment of the unambiguity of content of the guideline recommendation or conclusion of the systematic review/HTA | Assessment of content | (x)‡,§ | (x)‡ | x | − | − |
Complete operationalization | x‡ | x | − | n. a. | n. a. | |
Assessment of outcomes considered | Assessment of documentation | (x)§,|| | (x)|| | − | x | − |
Assessment of content – completeness | − | − | − | − | − | |
Assessment of content – patient relevance | x | − | − | − | − | |
Complete operationalization* | − | n. a. | n. a. | n. a. | n. a. | |
Assessment of the literature search | Assessment of documentation | x | x | − | x | x |
Assessment of content – currency | x | − | − | − | − | |
Assessment of content – completeness† | x | x | − | − | − | |
Assessment of content – plausibility | x | x | − | − | − | |
Complete operationalization* | − | - | n. a. | n. a. | n. a. | |
Assessment of study selection | Assessment of documentation | x | x | − | x | x |
Assessment of content | x | x | − | x | − | |
Complete operationalization* | − | − | n. a. | − | n. a. | |