Skip to main content

Table 1 Major features and concerns of preventive health behavior-related interventions

From: Mental model-based repeated multifaceted (MRM) intervention design: a conceptual framework for improving preventive health behaviors and outcomes

Issues

Category

Key feature

Concern/advantage

Approach

Single

Only one treatment

Treatment effect wanes over time

Multifaceted

Multiple treatments

Persistent treatment effect

Frequency

Single intervention

One round

Treatment effect wanes over time

Multiple intervention

Several rounds

Creates more persistent effect

Balance test

Socioeconomic and demographic factors

Income, wealth, age, sex, education

Mental model or cognitive capacity-related factors are mostly absent

Treatment component

Informational

Information-based letter

Less effective

Educational

Education

Effective but depends on the curriculum

Training

Hands-on experience

Effective but depends on the type and length of training

Financial

In cash only

Attractive but ineffective if stopped

Promotional

In kind or service

Highly effective with other treatments

Behavioral

Weak or strong norm-based nudging

Highly effective with other financial treatments

Mixed

Both financial and behavioral

More effective than either financial or behavioral alone

Time dimension

Short-term

Less than one year

Treatment effects wanes over time

Medium-term

One to five years long

Better than short-term intervention

Long-term

More than five years

Creates a more persistent effect

  1. We reviewed water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH)-related prevention health education and promotional interventions, (e.g., systematic reviews, empirical evidence) to explore the major features and concerns