The value of one versus three sputum smear examinations for diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis in Asella hospital, South-East Ethiopia
BMC Research Notes volume 10, Article number: 455 (2017)
The aim of the study is to compare the value of a single with three sputum smear examinations in the detection of smear-positive pulmonary tuberculosis.
There were a total of 7012 patients studied out of which 3599 (51.3%) were males and the rest females. In 637 (9.1%) of the patients, two or more smears were positive for AFB. 616 (96.7%) of the sputum smear positive patients had positive smears on the first spot sputum exams as compared to 635 (99.7%) who were positive on the morning sputum, (P = 0.000064). 598/637 (93.9%) of sputum smear positive patients had positive smears in all three smears regardless of the smear grading. A single morning smear examination is as sensitive as doing three sputum smear examinations in the diagnosis of sputum smear positive TB. The incidence of sputum smear positivity differed significantly across age groups, but did not differ between genders.
Tuberculosis is a major global health problem causing ill-health among millions of people each year and ranks alongside the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) as a leading cause of death worldwide. Ethiopia is one of the 22 high burden countries with incidence (including TB + HIV) of 207/100,000 population . Pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) has been of public health concern because sputum smear positive patients are the most infectious and most likely to transmit their dis-ease in their surroundings; they are the focus for infection control measures . The diagnosis rests mainly on isolation of the causative organism from the appropriate specimen (sputum, lymph nodes, body fluids, etc.) by direct microscopy or culture. Recent advancement and technology in field has made it possible to make the diagnosis by serological, immunological and gene analysis [3,4,5,6,7]. But these tests have a limited sensitivity and/or specificity for detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (M tuberculosis), or are inaccessible to the developing world where the disease burden is at the climax, due to economic and technological limitations. International union against tuberculosis and lung diseases (IUALD), the World Health Organization (WHO), and the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia (FDRE) national tuberculosis control program prepared guidelines recommend three sputum specimens; i.e. spot-morning-spot for diagnosis of new PTB cases [8,9,10,11].
The diagnosis of PTB is made if any two of the three sputum smears are positive for Acid Fast Bacilli (AFB) and is graded from 0 to 3+ .
To submit three sputum samples, patients need to stay for at least 2 days in the hospital. This has significant influence on the patients in terms of time and money they spend and leads to some patient loss. Processing multiple sputum smears leads to increased workload for the laboratory staffs and incurs additional cost for the health institution. If examining a single sputum smear sample gives the same result as examining three sputum smear samples without missing the smear positive TB patients, it would be advantageous for the patients, the laboratory personnel and the hospital for efficient resource utilization. Therefore, this study aims to know the overall sputum AFB positivity rate in the study population, to see the yield of sputum smear positivity in the three sputum samples, to see the difference in the sputum smear grade among the three samples, and to know the age group most affected by smear positive pulmonary TB.
A retrospective, cross-sectional study was done in Asella hospital, on laboratory records of all sputum smear examinations done for suspected pulmonary TB patients between May 01, 2014 and September 30, 2015. Asella hospital is 175 KM South-East of the Capital, Addis Ababa. It is one of the regional referral hospitals, serving for estimated 3.5 million people.
Records of sputum smear done in Asella hospital during the study period for suspected TB patients above the age of 15, were retrieved. Sputum smear results with incomplete bio-data and for those who are already on anti-TB treatment were excluded from the study. The data were entered to a prepared format on SPSS software (version 21.0), consisting of patients’, age, gender, sputum AFB status, sputum AFB for spot, morning and spot exam grading using Zhiel-Neelson method according to WHO and IULD recommended protocol [8, 9]. The technique consists of making a smear and drying it for 15–30 min, fixing it over the flame and staining with steaming hot carbol fuchsin for 5 min, decolorisation with 25% sulphuric acid for 2–4 min and counterstaining with 0.1% methylene blue for half a minute and examining under oil immersion lens of microscope. The number of positive smears of the first spot (the first spot sputum collected as the patient appears to laboratory), morning (the next day morning sample before having breakfast) and the second spot smears spot (the next day spot sample while the patient submits the morning sample) were compared with each other and with the two positive smears of the national standard to initiate anti-TB treatment. Continuous variables were described as mean (±standard deviation). Categorical variables were described as proportion and were analyzed to compare the significance of difference in distribution by using Chi square test. The difference in distribution was considered significant if p-value was less than 0.05.
There were a total of 7012 patients who fulfilled the inclusion criterion out of which 3599 (51.3%) were males.. In 637 (9.1%) of the patients, two or more smears were positive for AFB fulfilling the national standard criterion to initiate anti-tuberculosis (anti-TB) medications.
Six Hundred Sixteen of the sputum smear positive patients had positive smears on the first spot sputum smears (96.7%) as compared to 635 (99.7%) on the morning sputum (P = 0.000064) (Table 1).
One Hundred Fifty-Two (23.9%) of sputum samples in spot 1 and 152 (24.8%) in spot 2 had high smear grades (i.e., 3+), while they were 228 (35.8%) in morning sputum smear (P = 0.00001) (Additional file 1: Figure 1). Five Hundred Ninety-Eight (93.9%) of sputum smear positive patients had positive smears in all three smears regardless of the smear grading (Table 2); 44.3% of them had the same sputum smear grading (Additional file 1: Figure 2).
There is significant difference in sputum smear positivity among age groups: 303 (15.3%) of all smears done are positive in the 15–25 age group as compared to 256 (8.8%) in 26–45 (P < 0.00001) (Table 3).
There was no difference in smear positivity between genders: 346 in males and 291 in females (P = 0.113).
The sensitivity of sputum microscopy has been reported to vary 20–80%, often depending on different factors . The smear positivity among TB suspects in this study population was 9.1%, higher than that reported from study done in Tanzania tertiary hospital (6.1%) , but much less than that done in Rwanda (17.3%) , Turkey 42%  and Pakistan (52%),  where three consecutive morning sputum samples were examined. As the Bugando Medical Center in Northern Tanzania is a referral, consultant and teaching hospital, it may have contributed to the apparently lower yield of AFB in this patient population. The higher yield of smear positivity in later studies may be due to the high yield of AFB from the morning sputum sample. A one and half-year study done in India showed a smear positivity rate of 13.1% . Another study from the same country for 2 years showed a smear positivity of 19.2% in 1998 and 24.9% in 1999 . A more recent study from India showed a smear positivity rate of 16% with a positivity rate of 98.3, 98.6, and 96.9% for spot 1, morning, and both sputum smear examinations, respectively . This is similar to the finding in our study: spot 1, morning and spot 2 showing 96.7, 99.7 and 97%, respectively (P = 0.55). But earlier study from India showed 86.5% in spot 1 in 1998 and 90.5% in 1999, 98.5% in the morning specimen in 1998 and 96.4% in 1999, and in spot 2, 83% in 1998 and 85.9% in 1999 (P < 0.001 in both years) . The study from Tanzania showed the positivity rate for the first smear of 94.2% with incremental rate of 5.2 and 0.6% for the second and third smears, respectively . Similar findings are reported from study done in Rwanda : 92% detected in the first spot exam.
In addition, 93.9% of smear positive patients in this study had positive smears in all the three smears done regardless of smear grading, as compared to only 79% in the Indian study above. The difference may be due to quality of the sputum sample and set up under which the studies were done.
Examining multiple smears did not significantly increase the sputum smear positivity in Asella hospital. Much resource (time, money, laboratory chemicals, and human labor) was lost by dealing with multiple smears without getting additional advantage of more smear positives. In addition, it lead to delay in starting anti-TB medications.
The morning sputum sample showed a significant high-grade positivity. High-grade smear positivity is associated with lower smear conversion rate at the end of intensive phase of anti-TB treatment, and even after extending it for 1 month; therefore they are likely to remain infectious with high disease transmission [20, 21] and have less TB treatment outcome . Therefore, examining the morning sputum sample alone can detect almost all patients likely to have smear-positive TB as well as more patients that are likely to have highly infectious TB. But this requires 2 days to stay in the health institution likely leading to some patient loss. For those laboratories with external quality assurance, the current WHO recommendation is to switch to same-day diagnosis using spot–spot smears, [23, 24] This is also supported by a more recent systematic review and meta analysis .
No gender difference in smear positivity in this study, but there is significant age difference; the highest smear positivity is seen in the 15–25 age group. This is similar to the study done in Rwanda . Ethiopia has a broad-based- pyramid population pattern. Therefore, much of the young and productive age group that can play significant role in the country’s economic development, are being affected heavily.
As the study is retrospective, it may affect the findings. It may not be possible to generalize and apply the findings to other hospitals with fewer resources in Ethiopia.
acid fast bacilli
Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia
human immunodeficiency virus
International Union against Lung Diseases
Statistical Package for Social Sciences
World Health Organization
WHO. Global tuberculosis report 2015. 20th ed. Geneva: WHO; 2015.
World Health Organization. WHO policy on TB infection controls in health care facilities, congregate settings and households. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2009. (WHO/HTM/TB/2009.419).
Hajlabdolbaghl M, Rausalinejad M, Davoudi AR, Alikhani A, Najafi N. Application of peripheral blood Mycobacterium tuberculosis PCR for diagnosis of tuberculosis patients. Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci. 2014;18:185–9.
Steingart KR, Schiller I, Horne DJ, Pai M, Boehme CC, Dendukuri N. Xpert® MTB/RIF assay for pulmonary tuberculosis and rifampicin resistance in adults (Review). Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2014;(1):CD009593. https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD009593.pub3.
WHO. Fluorescent light-emitting diode (LED) microscopy for diagnosis of tuberculosis: policy statement. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2011.
Teran R, de Waard JH. Recent advances in the laboratory diagnosis of tuberculosis. eJIFCC. 2015;26(4):295–309.
Senol G. Laboratory diagnosis of tuberculosis-latest diagnostic tools in: tuberculosis—current issues in diagnosis and management INTECH; 2013.
WHO. Treatment of tuberculosis: guidelines 2010. 4th ed. Geneva: WHO/HTM/TB/2009.420; 2010.
IUATLD. Sputum examination for tuberculosis by direct microscopy in low income Countries: technical guide. 5th ed. Paris: IUATLD; 2000.
FMoH. Guidelines for clinical and programmatic management of TB, TB/HIV and leprosy in Ethiopia. Addis Ababa: FMoH; 2013.
Tb CAREI. International standards for tuberculosis care. 3rd ed. The Hague: TB CARE I; 2014.
Steingart KR, Ramsay A, Pay M. Optimizing sputum smear microcopy for the diagonosis of pulmonary tuberculosis. Expert Rev Anti Infect Ther. 2007;5:327–31.
Seni J, Kideniya BR, Obassy E, et al. Low sputum smear positive tuberculosis among pulmonary tuberculosis suspects in a tertiary hospital in Mwanza, Tanzania. Tanzan J Health Res. 2012;14(2):1–9.
Muvunyi CM. Prevalence and diagnostic aspects of sputum smear positive tuberculosis cases at a tertiary care institution in Rwanda. African Journal of Microbiology Research. 2010;4(1):088–91.
Ozkutuk A, Terek G, Coban H, Esen N. Is it valuable to examine more than one sputum smear per patient foe the diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis? Jpn J infect Dis. 2007;60:73–5.
Khattak MI, Ihsanullah K, Muhammad A, Khan N, Zaman M. Frequency of sputum positive AFB cases among patients of pulmonary tuberculosis in tertiary care hospitals of Northern Pakistan. J Ayub Med Coll Abbottabad. 2010;22(2):56–60.
Hamid S, Hussain SA, Imtiyaz A. Screening tuberculosis suspects: how many sputum specimens are adequate? Ann Trop Med Public Health. 2012;5:317–20.
Sarin R, Mukerjec S, Singla N, Sharma PP. Diagnosis of tuberculosis under RNTCP: examination of two or three sputum specimens. Indian J Tuberc. 2001;48:13.
Chauhan RC, Purty AJ, Samuel A, Singh Z. Incremental yield of second sputum smear examination for diagnosis of tuberculosis patients at a tertiary care teaching hospital in Puducherry, India. J Med Soc. 2016;30:89–93.
Lohmann EM, Koster BFPJ, Le Cessie S, Kamst-van Agterveld MP, van Soolingen D, Arend SM. Grading of a positive sputum smear and the risk of Mycobacterium tuberculosis transmission. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2012;16(11):1477–84.
Tiwari S, Kumar A, Kapoor SK. Relationship between sputum smear grading and smear conversion rate and treatment outcome in the patients of pulmonary tuberculosis undergoing dots–a prospective cohort study. Indian J Tuberc. 2012;59(3):135–40.
Rajpal S, Dhingra VK, Aggarwal JK. Sputum grading as predictor of treatment outcome in pulmonary tuberculosis. Ind J Tub. 2002;49:139.
WHO. Proposal for a revision of the case definition of “sputum smear-positive tuberculosis. Geneva: WHO; 2007.
WHO. Same-day diagnosis of tuberculosis by microscopy: policy statement. Geneva: WHO; 2011.
Davis JL, Cattamanchi A, Cuevas LE, Hopewell PC, Steingart KR. Diagnostic accuracy of same-day microscopy versus standard microscopy for pulmonary tuberculosis: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Lancet Infect Dis. 2013;13:147–54.
Heartfelt thanks go to Asella hospital laboratory staffs that kept and provided the records for this study. Grateful thanks also go to Asella hospital administration who allowed me to get these records.
The author declares that he has no competing interests.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets used and/or analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Consent to publish
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The study is approved by the research and ethical committee of the college of Health Sciences, Arsi University/Ethiopia. The consent to participate is not required because the study was retrospective. The permission to get the records is obtained from the hospital administration.
No funding was granted to this study.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Beyene, F. The value of one versus three sputum smear examinations for diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis in Asella hospital, South-East Ethiopia. BMC Res Notes 10, 455 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13104-017-2797-0
- Pulmonary tuberculosis
- Sputum smear