- Research note
- Open Access
The pattern of color change in small mammal museum specimens: is it independent of storage histories given museum-specific conditions?
BMC Research Notesvolume 11, Article number: 424 (2018)
Determination of color and evaluating its variation form the basis for a broad range of research questions. For studies on taxonomy, systematics, etc., resorting to mammal specimens in museum collections has a number of advantages over using field specimens. However, if museum specimens are to be for studying color, they should accurately represent the color of live animals, or we should understand how they differ. Basically, this study addresses this question: How does coat color vary when dealing with specimens of Akodon budini (Budin’s grass mouse, Thomas 1918), stored in one museum collection for different periods of time?
We measured color values through a spectroradiometer and a diffuse illumination cabin and used the reflectance values in the form of CIELab tri-stimulus values, considering CIE standard illuminant A. We observed that there is a relationship between specimen storage antiquity and pelage color and it seems that it is general for at least a number of small mammals and this could indicate a universal phenomenon across several mammal species and across several storage conditions. Our results, as others, emphasize the importance of considering storage time, among other circumstances, in research studies using mammal skins and where color is of importance.
Since the stored specimens in the biological and paleobiological collections have associated core data that are recognized as fundamental for discipline-specific research [1, 2], as well as for broader global issues and public initiatives , existing collections in Natural History museums are often the basis of numerous studies in taxonomy, systematics, ecology, biogeography, management, conservation, etc. [1, 4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12], and studies based on biological museum specimens are to a large degree the basis of our understanding of the diversity of life on Earth [6, 13]. In this framework, determination of color and evaluating its variation form the basis for a broad range of research questions. Accordingly, color itself is often the primary target of museum-based studies.
Resorting to mammal specimens in museum collections has a number of advantages over using field specimens, given the taxonomic, geographic, and temporal range of samples, which is near impossible to achieve by sampling in the wild . Particularly for terrestrial vertebrates, historic specimens stored in collections have been productively used in quantitative and comparative studies . Because research involving the study of coat color in mammals is better if it includes a wide-range sample, those studies often rely on specimens stored in museums.
If museum specimens are to be for studying color, they should accurately represent the color of live animals, or we should understand how they differ . There have been numerous investigations related to temporal changes in coloration of bird specimens in museum collections [e.g., 14, 16,17,18,19,20,21,22]. In all cases, the results showed substantial differences in the measured reflectance spectra of newer and older specimens. Meanwhile, variations of the coat color of mammal specimens in relation to storage time have not been studied, with few exceptions [e.g., 23, 24]. As other colors of the animals, coat color is susceptible to deterioration with time due to chemical or structural degradation of pigments that may result in the alteration of their optical properties . Besides, it has been found that color of museum specimens other than mammals is influenced by specimen preparation, preservation process, and storage histories [14, 22]. This effect has been acknowledged explicitly as a possible limiting factor in research on collection material [22,23,24]. Therefore, it seems reasonable to ask to what extent the color of museum mammal specimens may be considered an acceptable representation of the color of live animals [20, 22].
Our main goal was to apply an objective color measurement methodology to the detection, if any, of patterns of changes in the fur color of specimens of a small mammal species, Akodon budini (Budin’s grass mouse, Thomas 1918), in relation to the storage time (given the museum-specific preparation, preservation and storage conditions). By doing this, we aim to assess the use of museum collections in research on mammal color.
Materials and methods
We studied the same Akodon budini series previously studied for other purposes [25, 26]. For analyses we used skins from 54 adult specimens (Additional file 1). All specimens have been skinned and stored with the same methods .
We matched sex, collection dates (month and year) and occurrence localities (recorded from the information on specimen tags) to each specimen color data. Collection year ranged from 1970 to 2008.
As we did in our previous studies [25, 26] we measured color data (Additional file 2) through a Photo Research PR715 spectroradiometer and the SpectraWin 2 software, and inside a diffuse illumination cabin. This instrument measures the sample spectral reflectance. From the reflectance values, tri-stimulus values, which may be defined according to different systems , can be derived . We worked with the CIE (Commission Internationale de L’Eclairages, or International Commission on Illumination) Lab color system (Additional file 2). We selected the CIE Lab color space  because it is based on the human visual model, and therefore includes all of the colors perceived by humans , and it is more appropriate for the biological aims of this study . For calculation of these tri-stimulus values, it is imperative the use of standard conditions for observation, which includes the determination of one of the several types of standard illuminants defined by the CIE. We worked with the CIE standard illuminant A, which represents typical, domestic, tungsten-filament lighting.
We recorded the chromatic coordinates of five points (neck, upper back, middle back, lower back, and rump) over the dorsal middle line of each specimen (Additional file 3).
We used the computer statistical package INFOSTAT (2013 version) to conduct all statistical analyses over color data. We used Principal Component Analysis (PCA) to describe the association between the color variables, the independent variables, and each of the observations [32,33,34,35,36]. We then used general linear models of analysis of variance (ANOVAs) to examine relationships between color data and sample antiquity, and to explore the relationships between color data and sex, collection season, and sampling location. We included specimen identity as a random effect. We included in the analysis all interaction terms. We then proceed to model simplification and removed each non-significant (p > 0.05) interaction term. We used as post hoc test the Fisher’ LSD statistic with Bonferroni correction. Significance was accepted when p < 0.05. Finally, we report results related to those parameters that explain substantial variation in each dependent variable as determined by model fitting.
In Additional file 4, we present plots of the evolution of the color variables against their antiquity.
In Fig. 1 we painted dots according to their sample age. With respect to PC1, overlapping of the three dot clouds is extensive; however, most dots corresponding to specimens collected in the 1970s are located toward the right, in the direction of increasing values of a* and b*, and to a lesser extent of L*. The opposite applies to dots corresponding to specimens collected in the 2000s: they are located to the minimum values of a* and b* (and to a lesser extent of L*). Moreover, 1970s’ dots are highly displaced relative to the two other dot clouds: no 1990s’ or 2000s’ dots reaches the values of the 1970s’ dots located to the right. With respect to PC 2, while overlapping of the three dot clouds is again extensive, most 1970 dots are located down, in the direction of (moderate) increasing values of a* and b*, and decreasing values of L*. The opposite applies to the 2000 dots, which are located upwards, in the direction of (moderate) decreasing values of a* and b*, and increasing values of L*. In any case, dots corresponding to specimens collected in the 1990s have an intermediate position.
Anova (Table 2)
Color data measured in specimens stored for different periods of time are significantly different. We also found significant interactions between sample antiquity and measuring point  (Table 2). These results was found for two of the color variables, those that account for chromaticity (a* and b*; Table 2). This indicates that chromaticity, but not lightness (L*), varies in relation to measuring points and that this variation occurs at significantly different rates in different antiquity samples.
Similar to what happens with other biological pigments, the melanin-based colors may change over time due to chemical or structural degradation, from the time the mammal specimens are collected in the field, and during their storage in museum collections. Since museum collections of mammal specimens provide an important resource for evolutionary investigations of mammal phenotypic diversity, we examined this essential source of variation in physical measurements of a given small mammal species coloration and addressed the impact of time since collection on pelage color. We found that there is a relationship between specimen storage antiquity and pelage color in the Akodon budini studied sample: specimens get yellower and redder with storage antiquity. It could be said that the observed color change corresponds to the natural aging of the coat and its pigments, which is determined by the prevailing storage conditions.
Studies of changes in plumage coloration across storage have sometimes deal with melanin-based colors. Particularly,  examined not only color variations in carotenoid-based pigments of the feathers (as many studies dealing with bird coloration) but also the black melanin-based color. These results are relevant since they can be compared to the melanin-based color of mammals . According to , feathers with melanin-based colors tend to have higher red chroma in older specimens. They speculated that eumelanin (the one of the two melanin pigments that is responsible for dark colors) may be more susceptible to degradation than pheomelanin (the other melanin pigment, responsible for yellow and red colors). If this is the case, eumelanin degradation over time led to reduced proportions of this pigment in the feathers, resulting in feathers slightly reddish . Similarly,  found that the coat color of a red bat species (Lasiurus borealis) vary significantly with the antiquity of the specimens, with older specimens having redder shades of pelage than newer ones. Considering those results, it seems likely that the pelage of Akodon budini may have suffered breakdown of eumelanin pigment in the hair fibers, as suggested by , which would result in greater proportions of the redder pheomelanin pigment and a redder overall coat color in older specimens .
This eumelanin–pheomelanin relative proportions hypothesis may also be the explanation of why the interaction of Antiquity × Point is highly significant for a* and b* color variables (Table 2). As we established in our previous work , color determinations strongly depend on the measuring point, even on the same body area. In , for most studied specimens, the values of the variables a* and b* decreased in a neck-rump direction in specimens of the same age: those specimens are naturally redder and yellower to their necks, which may indicate that near their heads, hairs have relatively more pheomelanin. If this is the case, eumelanin degradation will be more evident near their tails.
Assessing the limitations of using museum specimens for characterizing the pelage color of small mammals implies to reflect on the usefulness of the study of museum specimens for characterization, identification, and discrimination of different taxonomic units based on color. Knowledge and understanding of color variation with specimens storage time in a given museum collection could allow researchers to correctly interpret the pelage color of specimens with different antiquities and to evaluate the differences in a framework of adequate interpretation, in order to precisely determine the limits of the color variation ranges of a particular taxonomic entity and to establish the usefulness of such ranges in identifying different taxa.
Since our and other studied mammal specimens are housed in Mammal Collections with very different storage conditions, it seems that there is a relationship between specimen storage antiquity and pelage color that is general for at least a number of small mammals and this could indicate a universal phenomenon across several mammal species and across several storage conditions. Our study does not intend to take away support from the use of museum specimens to examine intra or inter-specific pelage coloration in mammals. Our results, as those of  and , emphasize the importance of considering storage time, among other already mentioned circumstances, in research studies using mammal skins and where color is of importance.
Limitations include having worked with a sample of a single small mammal species from a single museum. However, our results aim to complement those previously obtained for other small mammal species from other museums. Even more, a more inclusive study is in process, in which numerous species coming from several museums (one of Argentina and 3 of the USA) are included.
Also we will use this study as an initial point of a long-term study.
Commission Internationale de L’Eclairages, or International Commission on Illumination
Suarez AV, Tsutsui ND. The value of museum collections for research and society. Bioscience. 2004;54:66–74.
Pyke GH, Ehrlich PR. Biological collections and ecological/environmental research: a review, some observations and a look to the future. Biol Rev Camb Philos Soc. 2010;85:247–66.
Vollmar A, Macklin JA, Ford LS. Natural history specimen digitization: challenges and concerns. Biodivers Inform. 2010;7:93–112.
Chapman AD. Uses of primary species-occurrence data, version 1.0. In: Report for the global biodiversity information facility, Copenhagen. 2005. http://www.gbif.org/document/80545. Accessed 19 Dec 2015.
Baird R. Leveraging the fullest potential of scientific collections through digitization. Biodivers Inform. 2010;7:130–6.
Drew J. The role of natural history institutions and bioinformatics in conservation biology. Conserv Biol. 2011;25:1250–2.
Rocha LA, et al. Specimen collection: an essential tool. Science. 2014;344:814–5.
Scoble MJ. Natural history museum and the biodiversity crisis: the case for a global taxonomic facility. Museum Int. 1997;49:55–9.
Rau JR. Biodiversidad y colecciones científicas. Rev Chil Hist Nat. 2005;78:341–2.
Funk VA, Richardson KS. Systematic data in biodiversity studies: use it or lose it. Syst Biol. 2002;51:303–16.
O’Connell AF, Gilbert AT, Hatfield JS. Contribution of natural history collection data to biodiversity assessment in national parks. Conserv Biol. 2004;18:1254–61.
Winston JE. Archives of a small planet: the significance of museum collections and museum-based research in invertebrate taxonomy. In: Zhang Z-Q, Shear WA, editors. Linnaeus tercentenary: progress in invertebrate taxonomy, vol. 1668., Zootaxa, Auckland: Magnolia Press; 2007. p. 47–54.
Winker K. Natural history museums in a postbiodiversity era. Bioscience. 2004;54:455–9.
Cassey P, Maurer G, Duval C, Ewen JG, Hauber ME. Impact of time since collection on avian eggshell color: a comparison of museum and fresh egg specimens. Behav Ecol Sociobiol. 2010;64:1711–20.
Cassey P, Hauber ME, Maurer G, Ewen JG. Sources of variation in reflectance spectrophotometric data: a quantitative analysis using avian eggshell colours. Methods Ecol Evol. 2012;3:450–6.
Kennedy EA. Color variation in museum specimens of birds: effects of stress, pigmentation, and duration of storage. Master’s Theses. Paper 25. 2010. http://digitalcommons.bucknell.edu/masters_theses/25. Accessed 19 Dec 2015.
McNett GD, Marchetti K. Ultraviolet degradation in carotenoid patches: live versus museum specimens of wood warblers (Parulidae). Auk. 2005;122:793–802.
Pohland G, Mullen P. Preservation agents influence UV-coloration of plumage in museum bird skins. J Ornithol. 2006;147:464–7.
Quesada J, Senar JC. Comparing plumage colour measurements obtained directly from live birds and from collected feathers: the case of the great tit Parus major. J Avian Biol. 2006;37:609–16.
Armenta JK, Dunn OP, Whittingham JA. Effects of specimen age on plumage color. Auk. 2008;125:803–8.
Cassey P, Ewen JG, Marshall NJ, Vorobyev M, Blackburn TM, Hauber ME. Are avian eggshell colours effective intraspecific communication signals in the Muscicapoidea? A perceptual modelling approach. Ibis. 2009;151:689–98.
Doucet SM, Hill GE. Do museum specimens accurately represent wild birds? A case study of carotenoid, melanin, and structural colours in long-tailed manakins Chiroxiphia linearis. J Avian Biol. 2009;40:146–56.
Davis AK, Castleberry SB. Pelage color of red bats Lasiurus borealis varies with body size: an image analysis of museum specimens. Curr Zool. 2010;56:401–5.
Davis AK, Woodall N, Moskowitz JP, Castleberry N, Freeman BJ. Temporal change in fur color in museum specimens of mammals: reddish-brown species get redder with storage time. Int J Zool. 2013;2013:876347. https://doi.org/10.1155/2013/876347.
Sandoval Salinas ML, Barquez RM, Colombo EM, Sandoval JD. Intra-specific pelage color variation in a South American small rodent species. Braz J Biol. 2016;77:1–11.
Sandoval Salinas ML, Sandoval JD, Colombo EM. Objective measurement of Akodon budini dorsal coloration: methodological concerns. An Acad Bras Cienc. 2016;88:489–502.
Díaz MM, Flores DA, Barquez RM. Instrucciones para la preparación y conservación de mamíferos, vol. 1. Tucumán: PIDBA Special Publications; 1998.
Schanda JD. Colorimetry. Chapter 9. In: Decusatis C, editor. Handbook of applied photometry. Woodbury: AIP Press; 1997. p. 327–412.
Schanda J, editor. Colorimetry. Understanding the CIE system. New Jersey: Wiley; 2007.
Ruiz JF, Pereira J. The colours of rock art. Analysis of colour recording and communication systems in rock art research. J Archaeol Sci. 2014;50:338–49.
Singaravelan N, Raz S, Tzur S, Belifante S, Pavlicek T, Beiles A, Ito S, Wakamatsu K, Nevo E. Adaptation of pelage color and pigment variations in Israeli subterranean blind mole rats, Spalax ehrenbergi. PLoS ONE. 2013;8(7):e69346.
Montgomerie R. Analyzing colors. In: Hill GE, McGraw KJ, editors. Bird coloration: mechanisms and measurements, vol. 1. Cambridge: Harvard University Press; 2006. p. 90–147.
Cuthill IC, Bennett ATD, Partridge JC, Maier EJ. Plumage reflectance and the objective assessment of avian sexual dichromatism. Am Nat. 1999;153:183–200.
Sokal RR, Rohlf FJ. Biometry. The principles and practice of statistics in biological research. 2nd ed. New York: W. H. Freeman and Company; 1981.
Otto M. Chemometrics: statistics and computer application in analytical chemistry. New York: Wiley; 1999.
Malinowski ER. Factor analysis in chemistry. 3rd ed. New York: Wiley-Interscience; 2002.
MLSS, JDS, and EMC designed the study and prepared the manuscript; MLSS and JDS took the data; RMB helped with data interpretation and was a contributor in writing the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
We thank Elena Bru (Centro de Referencia para Lactobacilos -CERELA, Argentina) and Raquel Castillo (ILAV, Argentina) for their help with statistical analysis. MLSS is grateful to the Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas (CONICET, Argentina) for providing her doctoral and postdoctoral fellowships and to the Agencia Nacional de Promoción Científica y Tecnológica and its Fondo para la Investigación Científica y Tecnológica for the PICT 2014-1843.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets generated and/or analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Consent for publication
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The Agencia Nacional de Promoción Científica y Tecnológica and its Fondo para la Investigación Científica y Tecnológica, by means of the PICT 2014-1843, partially financed the reported research, particularly in the collection and analysis of data.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.