Biomimetic hydrogel scaffolds via enzymatic reaction for cartilage tissue engineering
BMC Research Notes volume 15, Article number: 174 (2022)
We aimed to evaluate cytocompatibility of hyaluronic acid (HA) and gelatin (Gela) conjugation with phenolic groups (Phs) via enzyme-mediated crosslinking. Phenolic moieties were substituted on the backbone of HA (HA-Ph) and Gela (Gela-Ph) and subsequently were subjected for horseradish peroxidase crosslinking in the presence of H2O2 as an electron donor to create a stable hybrid microenvironment for cellular behavior and cartilage tissue engineering.
Successful synthesis of biopolymers confirmed by NRM and UV–Vis spectrophotometry. The physical characteristic of hydrogels including mechanical properties and water contact angle of hydrogels enhanced with addition of Gela-Ph in HA-based hydrogel. The Gela-Ph showed longest gelation time and highest degradation rate. The cellular studies showed cells did not attach to HA-Ph hydrogel. While, proper cell attachment and proliferation observed on blend hydrogel surface compared with the neat hydrogels which interpret by the existence of cell-adhesive motifs of utilized Gela-Ph in this hydrogel. The encapsulated cells in HA-Ph hydrogel were spheroid and just maintained their viability. Hydrogels containing Gela-Ph, the cells were spindle shape with high degrees of cytoplasmic extension. Overall, the results suggest that hybrid biomimetic hydrogel can provide a superior biological microenvironment for chondrocytes in 3D cartilage tissue engineering.
Articular cartilage with its distinct biomechanical and biochemical characteristics is important for the frictionless movement of articulating joints. Large articular defects are rarely healed even with continuous passive motion [1,2,3,4,5]. Until now, numerous experimental and clinical efforts have been made to induce the healing process within mature articular cartilage with the aim of re-establishing structurally and functionally endurable tissue [1, 2, 6]. Development of novel therapeutic approaches for the acceleration of healing in injured articular cartilage is at the center of attention [7, 8]. Hydrogels with biomimetic features can recapitulate tissue microenvironment biomechanically and biochemically and regulate cellular activity in vitro and in vivo [8, 9]. The ECM-derived compounds such as hyaluronic acid (HA), collagen, gelatin, elastin and glycosaminoglycan are assembled as 3D flexible matrices through various ways of crosslinking reaction [5, 10, 11]. The appropriate method and crosslinking can ensure durability and cellular viability as well as functionality during tissue development [5, 8]. The enzyme-mediated hydrogel formation specifically horseradish peroxidase (HRP) crosslinking is proven to be mild and effective when comparing existing physical and chemical approaches [7, 10, 12].
Among biomimetic substrates, HA is recognized as a major ECM component in a variety of tissues especially in load bearing tissues such as cartilage, tendon and bone due to its superior viscoelastic properties [7, 13,14,15]. The carboxylate functional groups of HA can be chemically modified or phenolated (HA-Ph) to facilitate crosslinking upon enzymatic reaction with tunable properties [13, 14, 16]. Although, the HA-Ph is a promising hydrogel for tissue engineering, the non-adhesive nature limits its application where cell attachment is involved [11, 13, 14]. The addition of gelatin (Gela) as a cell-interactive substrate to the HA-based hydrogel matrices can promote cell adhesion properties of the resultant hydrogels. This component is abundantly present in most of tissues and degrades due to its matrix metalloproteinase sensitive protein sequences. Incorporation of this component provide desirable biomaterial property for in vivo implanting hydrogels [14, 17, 18]. Likewise HA, the Gela structure can be chemically modified for enzymatic crosslinking [10, 14]. Furthermore, the phenolated Gela (Gela-Ph) manipulates the cellular adhesion and spreading due to its cell adhesive ligands. However, similar to collagen based hydrogels, enzyme-crosslinking Gela-based hydrogels are mechanically weak [10, 14, 19].
We expect the composite of HA/Gela hydrogel via HRP-crosslinking reaction would be evaluated for promotion of mechanical and biological characteristics. The potential of subject hydrogel was studied in 2D/3D architectures. Moreover, we have characterized physical properties of hydrogels such as mechanical strength, hydrophobic/hydrophilic and degradation behaviors as necessary factors to explore for cell behavior evaluation.
Materials and method
Sodium HA (MW:1.2 × 106 Da), Gela (Type A, 300 bloom), HRP, n-hydroxysuccinimide (NHS), 2-morpholinoethane sulfonic acid (MES), 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl) carbodiimide hydrochloride (EDC) and tyramine hydrochloride were obtained from Sigma (Saint Louis, MO, USA).
Synthesis of phenol conjugated HA and Gela
Biopolymers were synthesized by a general carbodiimide/active ester-mediated coupling reaction according to previous reports [11, 14]. Briefly, HA 1 g and Gela 5 g was gently added to the 100 mL MES solution 50 mM. Afterwards, 0.21 g of NHS, 0.42 g of EDC and 0.25 g of tyramine were sequentially added to each solution and stirred for 20 h. Then HA-Ph was harvested through several sequential precipitation using organic solvents. For Gela-Ph, the remaining chemicals were removed by dialysis against distilled water. Finally, each sample was freeze-dried (Telstar, Spain). The successful synthesis of biopolymers was confirmed through 1H NMR and substituted Ph amounts were measured by UV spectrophotometry (Shimadzu RF -5000) at 275 nm.
Gelation time of polymers were determined according previous reported study . The polymeric solution of 0.72% (w/v) HA-Ph and 3.6% (w/v) Gela-Ph was poured into a 48-well plate at 500 µL/well. Subsequently, the 50 µL HRP 12 unit/mL was added into well and homogenized at 50 rpm. In addition, under mixing, the 12 mM H2O2 50 µL was dripped into the well and timing was monitored once the magnetic stirring was halted and the surface of the solution swelled, this time was considered as a hydrogelation period.
Mechanical and degradation properties of hydrogel
The cylindrical hydrogel prepared for compression test and degradation tests. The compression-repulsion force profiles were measured using the cylindrical shaped hydrogels. The gels were placed in a Table Top Material Tester (EZ Test 500 N) installed with a flat probe of 8 mm in diameter and compressed at a crosshead speed of 2.0 mm/min. To study in vitro degradation, hydrogels were immersed into about 10 mL PBS solution. The samples were then incubated on shaker at 50 rpm and 37 °C. At the indicated time intervals, the samples were taken from the media, washed with the distilled water and weighted. The degradation extent was calculated as the remained mass of sample to its initial mass.
Cell on hydrogel surface
Freeze dried HA-Ph and Gela-Ph powder were soaked in 80% ethanol for sterilization and then dried using vacuum condition. The sterile samples were dissolved in PBS and poured into a 24-well plates. Then HRP and H2O2 solutions were respectively added to the well at 10:1:1 volume ratio, respectively. The final concentrations of HA-Ph, Gela-Ph, HRP and H2O2 were 0.5% (w/v), 3% (w/v), 1 unit/mL and 1 mM respectively. Prepared hydrogels were used for cell-adhesion study by adding culture media containing 5 × 104 ADSCs/wells.
PBS containing polymer precursor solution and ADSCs at 1.0 × 106 cells/mL was mixed with 1/10 (v/v) of concentrated solutions of HRP and H2O2, resulting in final concentrations of 1 unit/mL and 1 mM, respectively. Immediately after mixing, 400 µL of the polymeric mixture was poured into 24-well culture plate. The growth profile of encapsulated cells within hydrogels were evaluated via estimation of the mitochondrial activity using a colorimetric assay kit (WST-1) while the amount of water-soluble formazan dye derived from a tetrazolium salt dissolved in DMEM containing the cells showed their growth profiles. Besides, the ADSCs were stained with cell tracking dye kit-green to observe morphology of encapsulated cells in hydrogel using fluorescence microscope.
The conjugation of Ph moieties on resultant polymeric derivatives proved through 1H NMR analysis. As shown in Fig. 1A, B, HA-Ph and Gela-Ph NMR spectra were demonstrated appearance of characteristic peaks of Ph groups at 6.8–7.2 ppm chemical shift related to protons in ortho and meta position of conjugated Ph moieties [11, 17]. The degrees of substituted Ph moieties in HA-Ph and Gela-Ph were determined to be 1.81 × 10–4 mol-Ph/g-HA-Ph and 1.68 × 10–4 mol-Ph/g-Gela-Ph (Fig. 1C). The hydrogels from synthesized biopolymers prepared through HRP-mediated crosslinking (Fig. 1D).
The formation of the hydrogels was performed while HRP oxidizes the Ph groups to form free radicals which crosslink the aromatic rings by C–C and C–O coupling using H2O2 as an electron donor (Fig. 1D). The gelation time of hydrogels varied from few seconds until 35 s. Meanwhile, the Gela-Ph showed longest gelation time at 35 s (Fig. 2A). The gelation time of hybrid HA-Ph/Gela-Ph was shortest among hydrogels which could be due to higher amount of Ph moieties in this condition resulting higher density of crosslinking [16, 20]. The HA-Ph hydrogel demonstrated super-hydrophilic property by contact angle of 22 degree and incorporation of Gela-Ph in HA-Ph increased its hydrophobicity at 52 degrees (Fig. 2B). Regarding mechanical properties of hydrogels, while the lowest stability was related to the Gela-Ph hydrogel and broke at 52% strain with an ultimate compressive strength of 6.5 kPa (Fig. 2C). The Gela-Ph positively influence compressive strength and results showed that the HA-Ph/Gela-Ph hydrogel had the strongest compressive strength with the ultimate compressive strength of 35 kPa and broke at 64.4% strain (Fig. 2C).
One of the critical features of the implantable hydrogels is that the microstructures have to be degraded in a controlled fashion. As is shown in Fig. 2D, the Gela-Ph hydrogel degraded as a function of time until 31%. Degradation of HA-Ph/Gela-Ph was low (about 21%) and became most stable structure.
Biochemical evaluation of hydrogels
The ADSCs totally elongated and spread with reticular network formation on dish culture. Meanwhile, the minor of ADSCs observed on surface of HA-Ph hydrogel and their morphologies were totally in spheroid-shape without any cytoplasmic extension (Fig. 3A). In contrary, the ADSCs attached and elongated in Gela-Ph hydrogel in initial time of culture and showed totally spindle shape by increasing culture time. Interestingly, in HA-Ph/Gela-Ph hydrogel, the ADSCs showed good attachment and spreading similar with Gela-Ph hydrogel (Fig. 3A).
Encapsulated ADSCs did not grow within HA-Ph hydrogel and quantity of mitochondrial activity were remain statistically static without significant change until 7 days (Fig. 3B, C). The ADSCs were grown and proliferated more than 4 times in hydrogel Gela-Ph against to 2.5 times for hydrogel that was made by HA-Ph/Gela-Ph. Nearly the main of cells in HA-Ph were spheroid and could not elongate (Fig. 3C). Likewise, 2D study, hydrogels containing Gela-Ph could observe cell spreading and increase cell elongation affinity. The ADSCs surrounded in non-adhesive HA-Ph hydrogels had no spreading within 3D structure of the gel.
A variety of cell-laden hydrogels have been produced by Ph functionalization of different polymers such as alginate, silk, chitosan, collagen and HA and subsequent peroxidase-mediated crosslinking [5, 10, 20]. Among these biomaterials, the HA and Gela display minor frictional irritation to the surrounding tissues [9, 10, 18]. Also, the crosslinking approach and density within hydrogel matrix may cause the cytotoxicity behavior. Enzymatic crosslinking is a mild approach to induce the formation of 3D hydrogel networks [5, 20]. Here, HA-Ph and Gela-Ph successfully conjugated covalently with Ph groups and hydrogelated via the HRP-catalyzed oxidative crosslinking [21, 22]. The long gelation time of Gela-Ph hydrogel could be interpreted with required time for polymerization of low viscose Gela-Ph aqueous solution and increasing intramolecular network formation and hydrogelation . While, in hybrid condition density of crosslinkable Ph was highest compared with other groups which resulted fastest gelation. The HA-Ph demonstrated superior hydrophilic property and was tuned this property by incorporation of Gela-Ph which would be due to intrinsic properties of Gela-Ph as well as increasing degrees of crosslinking since Gela-Ph hydrogel showed lower hydrophobicity compare with HA-Ph/Gela-Ph hydrogel [7, 23]. The mechanical properties of hydrogel in hybrid condition proved upregulation of hydrogel stability compared with single composed hydrogels. Fabricating cartilage tissue construct is required stable structure to withstand against loading pressure and endured mechanically. Hence, the hybrid condition could be provided proper condition for cartilage tissue engineering due to its mechanical stability and moderate hydrophilicity [4, 8, 9].
The biological features of the prepared biomimetic hydrogels evaluated using hydrogels for 2D and 3D cell culture. As expected, cell morphology was different in the HA-Ph hydrogel with others hydrogels and low number of cells attached in spheroid shape [16, 24]. Cellular morphologies in Gela-Ph incorporated hydrogels were similar with conventional cell culture in spindle shape with filopedia formation which could be reasoned for effectiveness of Gela cell-adhesive motifs. Next, we analyzed the cellular morphology and proliferation ratio of encapsulated ADSCs. Similar with 2D culture for HA-Ph hydrogel, the morphology ADSCs was spheroid in this condition and no cell spreading observed at 7 days. On the other hand, in hybrid hydrogels, the cells were spindle shape and grew properly. In summary, these results recommended that using hybrid hydrogel could upregulate hydrogel specifications as a biomimetic cartilage microenvironment due to improved cellular growth and proliferation as well as biophysical properties of the substrate [4, 7,8,9].
Biomimetic hydrogels were obtained using aqueous HA-Ph and Gela-Ph solution containing HRP and H2O2. The developed hydrogels preserved their structure stability during the culture without specific cytotoxicity. The physical properties of developed hydrogels manipulated and upregulated by alteration of polymeric composition for cell culture system. The potency of prepared hydrogel for cartilage tissue engineering supported by viability of ADSCs in 2D and 3D microenvironment. These results demonstrate that the composite biomimetic hydrogel obtained through HRP-mediated crosslinking have the potential for application in the cartilage tissue engineering.
We showed possibility of HRP-mediated biomimetic hydrogel formation using synthesized HA-Ph and Gela-Ph. However, precise investigation is required for characterization and evaluation of composite HA-Ph/Gela-Ph hydrogel in different concentrations. Also, the quantitative and qualitative analyses on expression of cartilage tissue proteins and gens in evaluating hydrogel conditions are other important requirement to understand proper hydrogel condition for engineering cartilage tissue. It is recommended after optimization of hydrogel condition from physical and biological consistency for cartilage tissue engineering, examine the developed hydrogel for in vivo.
Availability of data and materials
The data created and analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable requests.
- Hyaluronic acid:
- H2O2 :
2-Morpholinoethanesulfonic acid, monohydrate
Nuclear magnetic resonance
Eyrich D, Brandl F, Appel B, Wiese H, Maier G, Wenzel M, Staudenmaier R, Goepferich A, Blunk T. Long-term stable fibrin gels for cartilage engineering. Biomaterials. 2007;28(1):55–65.
Jin R, Moreira Teixeira LS, Dijkstra PJ, Zhong Z, van Blitterswijk CA, Karperien M, Feijen J. Enzymatically crosslinked dextran-tyramine hydrogels as injectable scaffolds for cartilage tissue engineering. Tissue Eng Part A. 2010;16(8):2429–40.
Trachsel L, Johnbosco C, Lang T, Benetti EM, Zenobi-Wong M. Double-network hydrogels including enzymatically crosslinked poly-(2-alkyl-2-oxazoline) s for 3D bioprinting of cartilage-engineering constructs. Biomacromolecules. 2019;20(12):4502–11.
Ren Y, Zhang Y, Zhang H, Wang Y, Liu L, Zhang Q. A gelatin-hyaluronic acid double cross-linked hydrogel for regulating the growth and dual dimensional cartilage differentiation of bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells. J Biomed Nanotechnol. 2021;17(6):1044–57.
Song W, Ko J, Choi YH, Hwang NS. Recent advancements in enzyme-mediated crosslinkable hydrogels: In vivo-mimicking strategies. APL Bioeng. 2021;5(2): 021502.
Jürgensen K, Aeschlimann D, Cavin V, Genge M, Hunzker E. A New Biological Glue for Cartilage-Cartilage Interfaces: Tissue Transglutaminase*. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1997;79(2):185–93.
Ziadlou R, Rotman S, Teuschl A, Salzer E, Barbero A, Martin I, Alini M, Eglin D, Grad S. Optimization of hyaluronic acid-tyramine/silk-fibroin composite hydrogels for cartilage tissue engineering and delivery of anti-inflammatory and anabolic drugs. Mater Sci Eng C. 2021;120: 111701.
Ngadimin KD, Stokes A, Gentile P, Ferreira AM. Biomimetic hydrogels designed for cartilage tissue engineering. Biomater Sci. 2021. https://doi.org/10.1039/D0BM01852J.
Parratt K, Smerchansky M, Stiggersc Q, Roy K. Effect of hydrogel material composition on hBMSC differentiation into zone-specific neo-cartilage: engineering human articular cartilage-like tissue with spatially varying properties. J Mater Chem B. 2017;5(31):6237–48.
Khanmohammadi M, Dastjerdi MB, Ai A, Ahmadi A, Godarzi A, Rahimi A, Ai J. Horseradish peroxidase-catalyzed hydrogelation for biomedical applications. Biomater Sci. 2018;6(6):1286–98.
Khanmohammadi M, Sakai S, Taya M. Fabrication of single and bundled filament-like tissues using biodegradable hyaluronic acid-based hollow hydrogel fibers. Int J Biol Macromol. 2017;104:204–12.
Zhang W, Zhang Y, Zhang A, Ling C, Sheng R, Li X, Yao Q, Chen J. Enzymatically crosslinked silk-nanosilicate reinforced hydrogel with dual-lineage bioactivity for osteochondral tissue engineering. Mater Sci Eng C. 2021. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msec.2021.112215.
Darr A, Calabro A. Synthesis and characterization of tyramine-based hyaluronan hydrogels. J Mater Sci: Mater Med. 2009;20(1):33–44.
Khanmohammadi M, Sakai S, Ashida T, Taya M. Production of hyaluronic-acid-based cell-enclosing microparticles and microcapsules via enzymatic reaction using a microfluidic system. J Appl Poly Sci. 2016. https://doi.org/10.1002/app.43107.
Lee F, Chung JE, Kurisawa M. An injectable enzymatically crosslinked hyaluronic acid–tyramine hydrogel system with independent tuning of mechanical strength and gelation rate. Soft Matter. 2008;4(4):880–7.
Bagheri S, Bagher Z, Hassanzadeh S, Simorgh S, Kamrava SK, Nooshabadi VT, Shabani R, Jalessi M, Khanmohammadi M. Control of cellular adhesiveness in hyaluronic acid-based hydrogel through varying degrees of phenol moiety cross-linking. J Biomed Mater Res Part A. 2021;109(5):649–58.
Khanmohammadi M, Sakai S, Taya M. Impact of immobilizing of low molecular weight hyaluronic acid within gelatin-based hydrogel through enzymatic reaction on behavior of enclosed endothelial cells. Int J Biol Macromol. 2017;97:308–16.
Qu X, Yan L, Liu S, Tan Y, Xiao J, Cao Y, Chen K, Xiao W, Li B, Liao X. Preparation of Silk Fibroin/Hyaluronic Acid Hydrogels with Enhanced Mechanical Performance by a Combination of Physical and Enzymatic Crosslinking. J Biomater Sci Polym. 2021. https://doi.org/10.1080/09205063.2021.1932070.
Irvine SA, Agrawal A, Lee BH, Chua HY, Low KY, Lau BC, Machluf M, Venkatraman S. Printing cell-laden gelatin constructs by free-form fabrication and enzymatic protein crosslinking. Biomed Microdevice. 2015;17(1):1–8.
Williams RJ, Smith AM, Collins R, Hodson N, Das AK, Ulijn RV. Enzyme-assisted self-assembly under thermodynamic control. Nat Nanotechnol. 2009;4(1):19–24.
Khanmohammadi M, Zolfagharzadeh V, Bagher Z, Soltani H, Ai J. Cell encapsulation in core-shell microcapsules through coaxial electrospinning system and horseradish peroxidase-catalyzed crosslinking. Biomed Phy Eng Express. 2020;6(1): 015022.
Tomita K, Sakai S, Khanmohammadi M, Yamochi T, Hashimoto S, Anzai M, Morimoto Y, Taya M, Hosoi Y. Cryopreservation of a small number of human sperm using enzymatically fabricated, hollow hyaluronan microcapsules handled by conventional ICSI procedures. J Assist Reprod Genet. 2016;33(4):501–11.
Schuurmans CC, Mihajlovic M, Hiemstra C, Ito K, Hennink WE, Vermonden T. Hyaluronic acid and chondroitin sulfate (meth) acrylate-based hydrogels for tissue engineering: Synthesis, characteristics and pre-clinical evaluation. Biomaterials. 2021;268: 120602.
Davachi SM, Haramshahi SMA, Akhavirad SA, Bahrami N, Hassanzadeh S, Ezzatpour S, Hassanzadeh N, Kebria MM, Khanmohammadi M, Bagher Z. Development of chitosanhyaluronic acid hydrogel scaffolds via enzymatic reaction for cartilage tissue engineering. Mater Today Commun. 2022. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mtcomm.2022.103230.
This study was supported by a Grant (99-2-99-19142) from Iran University of Medical Sciences.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Consent for publication
Authors declare that they have a competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Khanmohammadi, M., Jalessi, M. & Asghari, A. Biomimetic hydrogel scaffolds via enzymatic reaction for cartilage tissue engineering. BMC Res Notes 15, 174 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13104-022-06060-w
- Biomimetic hydrogel
- Horseradish peroxidase-mediated crosslinking
- Cartilage tissue engineering