- Research article
- Open Access
Survey of physicochemical characteristics and microbial contamination in selected food locally vended in Morogoro Municipality, Tanzania
BMC Research Notesvolume 8, Article number: 727 (2015)
Raw milk, raw fruit juice and raw fish are enriched with essential nutrients for human diet but are prone to microbial contamination along the value chain. This cross sectional study was conducted to assess physicochemical characteristics and microbial quality of raw milk, fruit juice and fish from food vendors in Morogoro Municipality, Tanzania. The physicochemical assessment of food samples was done by smell, colour, presence of debris, turbidity, consistence, pH and clot on alcohol test. Hygiene of food containers, personnel and the vending environment was also assessed. Qualitative and quantitative microbial assessment of food was done using standard laboratory protocols as described by Tanzania Bureau of Standards and International Systems of Standards.
Raw milk sold in Morogoro was of poor quality since was adulterated with water, contained sediments and clotted on alcohol test. Up to 63 % of the milk samples were contaminated with Escherichia coli and 60 % had higher total viable count (TVC) than the recommended values. Raw fruit juice was stored in dirty containers and sold under unhygienic environment. Seventy-three percent of juice samples had TVC beyond the recommendations while E. coli contamination rate was 63.3 %. The raw fish samples had started spoiling as depicted through sensory evaluation. E. coli contamination rate was 55 % and that of Campylobacter jejuni was 0.5 %. The mean TVC of raw fish was 8.1 (Log cfu/g) and 96.2 % of the fish samples had TVC beyond the recommended limits of 5.0 Log cfu/g.
The physicochemical characteristics of food vended in Morogoro Municipality were of poor quality. The food had high bacterial contaminations. This situation poses health risks to the public and losses to food vendors due to spoilage. Stakeholders in food value chain should be educated on safe production and good hygienic practices. Routine quality and safety assessment of locally vended food, inspection of selling premises and regular health check-up of the personnel involved in food vending industry should be instituted.
Food- and water-borne pathogens are leading causes of illnesses in developing countries, causing deaths to about 1.9 million people annually at the global level . In developed countries, an estimated one-third of the population is affected by microbiological food-borne diseases each year . In Africa, food- and water-borne diseases are responsible for 33–90 % cases of mortality in children . Most of the cases are due to microbial contamination in food which is associated with poor hygiene in handling along food chain especially the street food. However, street food industry plays an important role in developing countries in meeting the food demands of the urban dwellers. Street foods feed millions of people daily with a wide variety of foods that are relatively cheap and easily accessible . According to FAO, street foods have significant nutritional implications for consumers, particularly from middle and low-income sectors of the population . Street food vendors in developing countries are often unlicensed, untrained in food hygiene and sanitation, and work under crude unsanitary conditions [5–8]. In Tanzania, urbanization accompanied with low wages offered to employees and labourers has led to proliferation of street food vendors who offer cheap meals that is always contaminated by microbes [9–11]. In a study to evaluate microbiological quality of ready-to-eat foods in Pemba Island, coliform bacteria, Salmonella spp. and Vibrio alginolyticus were the common contaminants .
Milk as a nutritious food is prone to microbial contamination and many milk-borne epidemics of human are spread through contaminated milk. The primary sources of microbial contamination in milk are the infected or sick lactating animals [12, 13]. The secondary causes of microbial contamination occur along the milk value chain from milk handlers, unsanitary utensils and/or milking equipments and water supplies used in sanitary activities [12, 13]. Studies show that up to 90 % of all dairy—related diseases are due to pathogenic bacteria like Brucella abortus, Escherichia coli 0157:H7, Mycobacterium bovis, Campylobacter jejuni and Staphylococcus aureus [14–16]. Moreover, fish is one of the most important protein sources for the rapid growing population in Tanzania. The per capita fish consumption has been estimated to be 25–30 kg . A large population in Tanzania lives nearby water bodies and the consumption of fish constitutes more than 50 % of the total animal protein source . However, fish are prone to microbial contamination from the sources when the water bodies are contaminated and along the value chain [19, 20]. When the fish are contaminated, the microbes accelerate spoilage and are the cause of food-borne diseases to consumers.
In addition, unpasteurized fruit juices pose a high public health risk especially in developing countries where strict food hygiene is limited [21–23]. Studies have reported pathogens like Salmonella spp., Shigella spp., E. coli O157:H7 and Listeria monocytogenes as common contaminants in juices with low pH [24, 25]. Most of the locally vended raw fruit juices in Tanzania are characterized with low pH [8, 11], a condition which favour survival of bacteria. The number of documented outbreaks of human infections associated with the consumption of raw fruits, vegetables, and unpasteurized fruit juices has increased in recent years [26, 27]. Unhygienic preparation, processing and handling of the raw fruit juices are the key sources of bacterial contaminations [8, 22]. A study by Simforian et al.  reported high microbial contamination in raw fruit juices locally vendered in Dar es Salaam city, something that poses a threat of food-borne diseases to consumers.
There has been a big number of food-borne diseases in Tanzania including diarrhoea, dysentery, typhoid and cholera , but it is not known how much of these diseases have been contributed by the consumption of contaminated street vended food like milk, fish and raw fruit juices. Milk, fish and fruits are nutritious food which nutritionists recommend them in the daily diets of humans but when are not well handled; they are the potential sources of food-borne diseases. Over 90 % of the people in Tanzania consume raw milk that predisposes them to infections . In cities like Morogoro, there has been an increase in consumption of freshly extracted fruit juices because of availability of variety of fruits throughout the year  but their safety is not known. This study aimed to assess the physical characteristics and establish the bacterial status of the selected food that is locally sold in Morogoro Municipality, Tanzania. The baseline data of this work will provide added information on status of microbial contaminations in food marketed in Tanzania. This will also be useful to public health officials in instituting control measures of food-borne diseases in Morogoro Municipality and Tanzania at large.
The study was conducted in Morogoro Municipality, Tanzania. Selection of the municipality, as the study area was based on convenience of accessibility from the laboratory and it generally represents food vending systems in urban areas of Tanzania.
The permission to carry out this study was granted by the Morogoro Municipal Director. The Vice Chancellor of Sokoine University of Agriculture (SUA) issued a research permit letter on behalf of The Tanzania Commission for Science and Technology (COSTECH) that permitted the researchers from SUA to conduct their research in Morogoro Municipality. Before commencement with the research, the study protocol was prepared, submitted to, and approved by the SUA ethical committee. Verbal consent was obtained from each of the food vendor after explaining the purpose and importance of the study prior to start of data collection. Participation in the study was on voluntary basis. In addition, before the manuscript was submitted to journal for publication, the data were submitted to the local ethics committee at SUA and to the Morogoro Municipal Director and permission to publish the results was granted.
Sampling and sample handling
Milk samples were collected from farmers, vendors and restaurants/milk kiosks in different wards and streets. At farm level, 20 raw milk samples were collected directly from the storage containers with the pooled milk. From vendors, nine raw milk samples were collected directly from the storage containers. Eleven boiled milk samples were collected from 11 randomly selected restaurants/milk kiosks. Before sampling, milk assessment for smell, colour, any dirty, turbidity, cleanliness of containers and milk handlers was done. The smell of milk was assessed after the farmer or vendor had opened the lid of the container. The colour was examined visually by putting well stirred milk in the clean glass container as described by Kurwijila et al. . About 250 ml of milk sample was collected from each source, put in a sterile glass bottles and placed in a cool box with ice packs during the field work. A total of 40 milk samples were collected and analysed.
The raw juice samples were collected from vendors in different places including 11 samples from the bus terminals, 10 samples from selected cafeterias and 9 samples along roadsides. Before sampling, juice assessment for smell, colour, dirtiness, cleanliness of containers and assessment of the environment was done. The juice samples were collected directly from the storage containers into sterile falcon tubes and placed in a cool box with ice packs before shipment to the laboratory for analysis. A total of 30 juice samples were collected and analysed.
Cleanliness of the fruit juice containers:
Clean: A container is obviously free from dirty substances such as abnormal stains, dried juice spillover on surfaces and has not changed its original colour due to wear and tear.
Satisfactory: no dried juice spillover, presence abnormal stains that cannot be removed by cleaning, container appears to have irreversibly changed its original colour but appears clean.
Dirty: refers to presence of dried juice spillover, change of original container colour and presence of abnormal stains that may be removable by cleaning.
Cleanliness of the environment at fruit juice selling points:
Dirty: the area around where juice is sold has discarded litter materials such as plastic bags, papers, poured water on the ground, sold nearby municipal drainage systems, near dump sites or any other materials that should not be discarded irregularly such as maize cobs, mango and orange peelings.
Clean: the area is free from above mentioned factors dirty environment.
Presence of dirty in fruit juice:
Yes: refers to presence of abnormal suspended particles such as sand, fruit peelings or any other materials that should not be present
No: refers to lack of obvious abnormal suspended materials.
Note that the following criteria were developed and used in assessment of hygienic practices in the juice handling environment as per FAO .
Freshwater and marine fish samples were collected from 14 fish shops and Mindu dam shoreline selling point. Before collection of samples, information on the type of fish (freshwater or marine), fish sources and means of package were collected. From the fish shop freezers, four representative fish samples were taken from different corners, each was put into separate sterile zipped plastic bags and placed in a cool box with ice packs. A total of 185 fish samples were collected from different fish selling points in Morogoro of which, 79 (42.7 %) were marine and 106 (57.3 %) freshwater fish. All the collected samples were being transported in a cool box with ice packs to the Faculty of Veterinary Medicine laboratory at Sokoine University of Agriculture for analysis within 2–3 h of collection.
Laboratory analysis of food samples
Physicochemical quality assessment of milk samples
Part of the milk samples was filtered using a clean white cloth and assessed for physical dirt/contaminants . In case of any debris remained on the white cloth; the milk was regarded as dirty. Determination of pH of milk was done by using Jenway 3540 pH and Conductivity Meter (Bibby Scientific Ltd, Staffordshire, UK) which was first calibrated using standard buffer solutions of pH 7.0 and pH 4.0 (ISO 7218:2007) . The used reference pH was 6.6–6.8 for raw cow milk as given by East African Community standards . Alcohol test was done to ascertain the milk acidity and it involved mixing a 5 ml aliquot of the milk sample with an equal volume of 70 % ethanol in a clean test tube and examined for the presence clots. Specific gravity was measured by use of a lactometer at standardized temperature of 20 °C . The used reference relative density for whole milk was 1.027–1.030 as given by East African Community standards .
Assessment of Escherichia coli and total viable count (TVC) in milk samples
Total viable count (TVC) for enumeration of microorganism in raw milk at 37 °C applied a protocol described by Tanzania Bureau of standards and ISO/FDIS 8261 (E) [35, 36]. Briefly, tenfold serial dilution of milk sample from 10−1 to 10−10 in sterile normal saline solution was done, using disposable pipettes. From each dilution, 1 ml of diluted sample was placed in a sterile Petri dish followed by the addition of 20 ml of molten nutrient agar (Oxoid Ltd, Basingstoke, UK), gently shaken and left to solidify. Incubation was done under aerobic condition at 37 ± 1 °C for 24 ± 3 h. Microbial colon count on the plates was done with the aid of portable magnifying lens and colonies in the culture plate were countered by using colony counter. Two consecutive plates with 30–300 colony forming units (cfu/ml) were considered for record . The countable microbial colonies from two consecutive plates of each sample were converted into colony forming units per millilitre (cfu/ml) using a formula N = ∑C/v × 1.1 × d, where N—number of microbial colonies counted, C—sum of colonies counted in two successful dilutions, v—volume of sample and d—dilution in the first plate counted .
Escherichia coli was determined in milk samples to assess for the possibilities of faecal contaminations. Briefly, 1 ml of milk sample was added into universal bottle containing 9 ml of buffered brilliant green bile glucose broth (EE broth) (Oxoid Ltd, Basingstoke, UK) then incubated at 37 °C for 24 ± 2 h under aerobic condition for enrichment. Thereafter, the sample was subcultured into tryptone water and incubated under the same conditions. Presence of E. coli was confirmed by addition of indole reagent in tryptone water and observed for presence of a red ring in the alcoholic phase which indicated indole production signifying a positive test. Isolation and identification of pure colonies of E. coli was done as described in ISO 7251:2005 protocol . Briefly, the enriched sample in EE broth was striped onto MacConkey agar and incubated at 37 °C for 24 ± 2 h under aerobic condition. Typical colonies of E. coli grown on MacConkey agar were dry, medium in size, pink in colour and appeared singular or in groups. Gram staining and biochemical reactions like oxidase, nitrate and indole tests were performed to confirm the presence of E. coli.
pH and microbiological determination in juice samples
The pH of juice samples was measured by using Jenway 3540 pH and Conductivity Meter (Bibby Scientific Ltd, Staffordshire, UK) after calibration using standard buffer solutions of pH 7.0 and pH 4.0 . Microbiological evaluation was done by establishing TVC and most probable number (MPN). Total viable count for enumeration of microorganism in raw juice at 37 and 45 °C applied a protocol described by Tanzania Bureau of standards and ISO/FDIS 8261 (E) [35, 36] as was described for the raw milk. For the determination of total coliform count (TCC) (coliform and faecal coliform bacteria), MPN, the presumptive test for coliforms was carried out using MacConkey broth (Oxoid Ltd, Basingstoke, UK) in the three test tube method as described by WHO . The three tubes with 10 ml of broth were inoculated with 1 ml from 10−1, 10−2, 10−3, 10−4 and 10−5 prepared dilutions and incubated at 37 °C for 24 h for coliforms and at 45 °C for faecal coliforms as described by WHO . All tubes showing gas production were observed and recorded. The MPN tables for three tubes dilution were used to report the result of the presumptive MPN of coliform bacteria per ml. E. coli was confirmed in samples as described above for the milk samples.
Physical assessment of fish samples
Upon arrival in the laboratory, fish samples were identified to species level using standard identification keys. Biodata details of fish like sex, weight, age and length was not determined. Fish samples from the freezers were allowed to thaw followed by physical assessment. Physical evaluations undertaken included smell, sight (appearance) and touch (consistence) as described by Codex guidelines for the sensory evaluation of fish and shellfish in laboratories . A special attention was directed to the eyes, gills, skin, texture and attachment of scales for the scaled fish like tilapia.
Microbiological assessment of fish samples
For the purpose of qualitative analysis, three bacteria groups were targeted namely E. coli, thermophilic Campylobacter and Salmonella spp. Isolation and identification of E. coli from fish swab samples started with enrichment in buffered brilliant green bile glucose broth (EE broth) (Oxoid Ltd, Basingstoke, UK) and all the other procedures were done as for the milk samples.
Fish swabs with samples for Campylobacter isolation were immediately placed in a sterile universal bottle containing 10 ml of Bolton broth (Oxoid Ltd, Basingstoke, UK) with antibiotic (cefoperazone 32 mg/l) supplements (Oxoid Ltd, Basingstoke, UK). The samples in the Preston broth were loaded in the microaerophilic candle jars (Coldstream Engineering Ltd, Arista, Sweden) with a lighting candle and incubated at 37 °C for 24 h for enrichment as described by Atabay and Corry . Isolation and identification of thermophilic Campylobacter was carried out according to the method described by Karmali et al. . Briefly, after incubation, the universal bottles with enriched samples were properly shaken and sub-cultured onto modified charcoal cefoperazone deoxycholate agar (Oxoid Ltd, Basingstoke, UK) for primary isolation of Campylobacter. The inoculated Petri dishes were incubated at 42 °C for 48 h under microaerophilic conditions and colonies resembling Campylobacter were sub-cultured onto blood agar (Oxoid Ltd, Basingstoke, UK) at 37 °C under microaerophilic conditions for 24 h. Suspected Campylobacter colonies on blood agar that were Gram negative, curved, or spiral rods and showed corkscrew-like motion; positive to catalase, oxidase and nitrate reduction tests were further tested for hippurate hydrolysis, H2S production, and susceptibility to nalidixic acid and cephalothin. These parameters formed the basis for the identification of C. jejuni, C. coli, or C. lari as described by On .
The swab samples for Salmonella isolation were put in sterile universal bottles containing 10 ml selenite cysteine broth (Oxoid Ltd, Basingstoke, UK). Isolation and identification of Salmonella species was carried out by using ISO 6579:2002 protocol .
Total viable count (TVC) of microorganisms in fish at 37 °C was performed using a protocol described previously . Briefly, 1 g of fish sample was grinded using sterile mortar and pestles and 10 ml of maximum recovery diluents (MRD) (Oxoid Ltd, Basingstoke, UK) was added and thoroughly mixed as described in EAS 217-1-3:2008 protocol . The TVC in fish sample at 37 °C applied a protocol described by Tanzania Bureau of standards and ISO/FDIS 8261 (E) [35, 36] as was described for the raw milk. After incubation all colonies were counted and the results reported as cfu/g.
The TVC values were log transformed before statistical analysis in order to make the frequency distribution more symmetrical. The Epi info version 2000 (approved by CDC, Atlanta, GA, US) was used for statistical analysis. Differences on means of TVC between groups of samples were compared by Mann–Whitney/Wilcoxon two-sample test. Means were considered significantly different at p < 0.05.
Physicochemical and microbiological quality of milk samples
Total of 40 milk samples were collected, whereby 11 were boiled milk and 29 were raw milk from Morogoro Municipality. It was found that the milk sold in Morogoro Municipality was of poor quality as depicted through physical and microbiological assessment. Three milk samples (7.5 %) had bad smell, 20 % were contaminated with cow dung, hairs and unidentified sediments, 25 % clotted on alcohol test and were the milk which had pH between 5.7 and 6.1. Majority (70 %) of the milk samples had low specific gravity (Table 1).
Microbiological results showed that the mean TVC of raw milk was 4.7 (Log cfu/ml) with the highest count recorded in raw unboiled milk samples (5.5–5.6 Log cfu/ml) particularly those which had bad smell and sediments (Table 2). Lowest microbial count (3.3–4.1 Log cfu/ml) was depicted in five boiled milk samples and three samples which had a pH of 5.7. Assessment of different sources of milk samples against differences in the means TVC showed the significant differences (p = 0.0000) with the highest mean TVC (4.9 Log cfu/ml) recorded in milk from vendors. The mean TVC (4.9 Log cfu/ml) in unboiled milk was higher than that of boiled milk (4.3 Log cfu/ml) and the difference was statistically significant (p = 0.0000). The figures described herewith are averages over all target categories of milk sources in this study as were depicted in Table 2. The overall results indicated that 60 % of all milk handled had higher TVC than the maximum recommended of 5.3 Log cfu/ml for raw milk as given by East Africa Community standards . A total of 25 (62.5 %) of the milk samples were contaminated with E. coli. This included all the eight milk samples from the farms which had sediments of dung and hairs.
Physicochemical and microbiological quality of juice samples
A total of 30 samples of locally vendered raw fruit juices from: cafeteria 10, along roadside 9 and from bus terminals 11 were collected and analyzed. Most of juice was made from mango (76.7 %) and mixture of fruits (passion, avocado and watermelon). The dominant colour was mango colour (yellow) and all the fruit juice had good smell and there were no dirty materials as contaminants. All the juice samples were acidic with pH range of 3.4–5.1 and 80 % of the vendors handled fruit juice in a clean environment. The container cleanliness assessment revealed that 43.3 % were dirty (Table 3).
Results for assessment of bacterial load in fruit juice by MPN and TVC are shown in Table 4. The MPN ranged between 460 and ≥1100 at 37 °C, while it ranged between 11 and ≥1100 at 44.5 °C. E. coli was identified in 63.3 % of the juice samples examined. Juice samples from bus terminal, roadside and cafeteria were contaminated with E. coli at the rates of 26.7, 23.3 and 13.3 %, respectively. The TVC varied from 4.2 to 6.3 Log cfu/ml at 37 °C and 4 to 5.9 Log cfu/ml at 44.5 °C. According to Gulf standards the TVC of any fruit juices should not exceed 3.4–4.7 log cfu/ml at 37 °C . Referring to this standard, 73.3 % of the fruit juice samples had TVC beyond the recommendations (Table 4).
Based on sources of samples, all the 11 samples collected at bus terminal had high coliform growth at 37 and 45.5 °C and also all samples had high TVC (>6.3 Log cfu/ml). Out of 9 fruit juice samples collected along roadside, 7 had coliforms and other microbial growths at 37 and 45.5 °C. Cafeteria samples had the least TCC and TVC at both temperature range of 37 and 45.5 °C. Assessment of different sources of juice samples against mean TVC and TCC showed no significant difference (p > 0.05) with the highest mean TVC (6.5 Log cfu/ml) recorded in juice samples from bus terminal.
Physical and microbiological quality of fish samples
A total of 185 fish samples were collected from different fish selling points in Morogoro of which, 79 (42.7 %) were marine and 106 (57.3 %) freshwater fish. Fourteen fish shops and Mindu dam shore fish selling points were involved in the study. The marine fish species were Siganus, Sardine, Caranx, Tuna and Lethrinus while freshwater fish species were tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus and O. urolepsis) and Clarias gariepinus. The physical appearance of the slime layer on fish skin to most fish (62 %) had started becoming turbid, opaque and milky. All the assessed fish had soft muscles with pitting characteristics on touch. The tilapia had their scales easily peeling off. Majority of the fish (80 %) generally appeared dull with loss of bloom, their eyeballs were sunken and cloudy, their gills appeared brown or gray covered with some mucus and others were greenish in colour. Forty-three percent of the fish had sour smell.
The prevalence of water-borne bacteria in fish was 54.6, 0.5 and 0.0 % for E. coli, C. jejuni and Salmonella spp. respectively. The only C. jejuni isolated was from freshwater fish (Tilapia) sourced from Mtera dam. Freshwater fish and unfrozen fish were more contaminated with E. coli than the marine fish and frozen fish respectively (p < 0.05) (Table 5). The mean TVC of raw fish was 8.1 (Log cfu/g) with the highest count recorded in freshwater unfrozen fish samples (8.9 Log cfu/g) from Mindu dam (Table 5). The lowest microbial count (4.2 Log cfu/g) was observed in frozen marine fish from Tanga. Comparisons of fish types, storage conditions and sources against differences in the means TVC showed significant differences (p = 0.0000). According to Tanzania criteria/guidelines established by Fisheries Act No. 22 of 2003 and Fisheries Regulations of 2003  it recommends that the TVC should not exceed 5.0 Log cfu/g for raw fish. With these results, 96.2 % the fish samples had TVC beyond the recommended limits .
The current study aimed to assess the physical quality and establish the microbial status in raw milk, raw fish and raw unpasteurized fruit juices locally sold in Morogoro Municipality, Tanzania. It was generally found that the milk sold in Morogoro Municipality was of poor quality as depicted through physical and bacteriological assessment. Unpasteurized raw fruit juice indicated high bacterial load which may be sources of spoilage and endangers the health of consumers. Similarly, fish bacterial analysis indicated high prevalence of E. coli as an indicator of faecal pollution in water and also isolated C. jejuni from freshwater fish. High proportion of food samples with poor physical quality and high bacterial loads as was observed during this study suggests that there is high risk of public exposure to food-borne diseases in Morogoro Municipality. Food producers and vendors should be educated on good and safe food preparations accompanied with good hygienic practices so as to safeguard the public from eating contaminated food. It is further stressed that there is a need for enforcement of regulations regarding the safety of locally vended food and routine inspection of food, selling premises and regular health check-up of the personnel involved in food vending industry.
Assessment of milk quality
Presence of physical dirt in raw milk serves as potential sources of microbial contamination and cause poor eye appeal to consumers that may lead to lowered marketability. Abnormally bad smell of milk observed during this study partly may be contributed by spoiled milk, dirty containers, contamination with dirty like cow dung, hairs and general poor milk hygiene. Similar observations have been reported by Bukuku et al. . Contaminations accelerate spoilage which may lead to milk-borne diseases to consumers. Large amount (70 %) of the milk sold had low specific gravity (SG) below standard of 1.028 g/ml as given by East African community  which suggests adulterations.
The results of the present study showed that (60 %) of all milk handled had higher TVC than the maximum recommended of 5.3 Log cfu/ml as given by East Africa Community standards . The mean TVC of raw milk was 3.4 Log cfu/ml with the highest count recorded in raw unboiled milk samples (5.5–5.6 Log cfu/ml). This suggests a considerable proportion of milk consumers are at risk of milk-borne diseases since majority of the people in Tanzania consume raw unboiled milk . Bacterial contamination of raw milk can occur from three main sources; within the udder, outside the udder, and from the surface coming into contact with the milk [12, 13, 48]. It was observed that among the milk samples with highest TVC were those with sediments (cow dung and hairs) which are potential sources of microbes acquired from the animal itself. In addition, farmers and other milk dealers may incur losses due to rejection of spoiled milk as was observed during this study, 25 % of the milk samples tested clotted on alcohol test. The results of this study are inline to those previously published in Tanzania by Bukuku et al.  and Kivaria et al.  in which most of the samples tested had higher bacterial count above the standards.
Surprisingly, a high mean TVC of 4.3 Log cfu/ml in boiled milk was recorded implying that boiling is not the only critical step for improving the microbiological quality of milk products. The unsatisfactory quality of boiled milk is the consequence of the poor quality of raw milk used and/or a high level of recontamination after boiling. Poor handling and storage of boiled milk in restaurants/kiosks observed during this study give high possibilities for post-boiling contaminations. These findings highlight the fact that boiled milk of such poor microbiological quality poses a threat to consumers. E. coli was isolated from 62.5 % of the milk samples analyzed. According to WHO guidelines, E. coli should not be present in any raw or processed milk since the bacteria are used as an indicator of faecal contamination. In addition, strains like E. coli O157:H7 are also pathogenic to humans and their occurrence has been reported in Tanzania .
Assessment of fruit juice quality
The general finding on fruit juice showed that it was prepared and served in unhygienic environments. Most of the containers (43.3 %) used to store juice were dirty while 20 % of the selling points were also dirty suggesting of contamination. Disregard of sanitary practices during juice preparation, storage in clean containers and vending in clean environment might be the possible cause of high bacterial load in fruit juices sold along roadsides and bus terminals as previously reported by Nonga et al. and Simforian et al. [8, 11]. This was supported by the high bacterial load in fruit juice samples beyond the recommendations. According to the Gulf standards, the allowable TVC levels for raw unpasteurized fruit juices should be within 3.7–4.0 Log cfu/ml . Majority of the fruit juices (73.3 %) in the current study had TVC above the recommended levels which imply poor quality. The TVC recorded in the current study varied from 4.2 to 6.3 Log cfu/ml at 37 °C and 1–5.8 Log cfu/ml at 44.5 °C which indicate a serious case of poor hygiene and the juice was unfit for consumption. This range is comparable to the findings reported by Simforian et al. ; it is however, lower than those reported by Kumar et al. . With these results, it calls for the routine screening and control of locally extracted fresh fruit juice which is being sold in streets by the local vendors in different town centers in Tanzania.
It was further found that majority of the samples were contaminated with coliforms in particular E. coli which indicates evidence of faecal contamination or poor hygiene and the juice was unfit for consumption. The main source of coliform contamination might be through contaminated water supplies which are used in processing of juice or the personnel . Assessment of food preparation areas indicated that majority of vendors prepared and sold juices in unhygienic conditions that attracted houseflies and dust. According to Tanzania Specifications (TZS 585:2003), coliforms like E. coli must not be present in ready to drink beverages . The E. coli prevalence recorded in the current study indicates that most of the raw unpasteurized fruit juice vended in Morogoro is not fit for human consumption and predisposes consumers to food-borne diseases.
Assessment of raw fish quality
Results on raw fish indicated that most of the fish were of poor quality since most of them were at different stages of spoilage and therefore unfitness for human consumption. High prevalence of E. coli (54.6 %) was recorded which indicates evidence of faecal contamination either from the water body, rapture of intestines during eviscerations or contamination along the fish value chain mainly due to poor hygiene and storage conditions. Some strains of E. coli are known to cause diarrhea, urinary infections, pyogenic infections and septicemia in humans [50, 54, 55]. Meanwhile, isolation of C. jejuni from tilapia sourced from Mtera dam poses more danger to fish consumers. Campylobacter jejuni has been reported in Tanzania as among the major causes enteritis in humans [55, 56].
Findings on bacterial enumeration in fish indicated that the mean TVC in freshwater fish was 8.3 Log cfu/g while in marine fish was 6.2 Log cfu/g. According to Tanzania criteria/guidelines established by Fisheries Act No. 22 of 2003 and Fisheries Regulations of 2005  it recommends that the TVC should not exceed 5.0 Log cfu/g meaning that 96.2 % of the fish samples had TVC beyond the recommendations. Other studies in Tanzania have also reported high bacteria count in freshwater and marine fish [20, 57]. High bacterial load in fish predisposes them to fast spoilage and possibly become potential sources of food-borne poisoning to consumers. This was evidenced by the results of physical assessment which showed majority of the fish were spoiled. In addition, presence of pathogenic bacteria like C. jejuni in raw fish poses a health risk to the consumers.
It is concluded that most of food vended in the Morogoro Municipality is of poor quality physically and microbiologically, which poses health risks to public and losses to food owners due to spoilage. Stakeholders in food value chain should be educated on safe production and good hygienic practices. Routine safety assessment of locally vended food, inspection of selling premises and regular health check-up of the personnel involved in food vending industry should be done.
buffered peptone water
Tanzania Commission for Science and technology
Food and Agriculture Organization
International Standards Organization
most probable number
a measure of the acidity or basicity of an aqueous solution
Population and Housing Census of Tanzania
Sokoine University of Agriculture
Tanzania Bureau of Standards
total coliform count
total viable count
United Nations Industrial Development Organization
World Health Organization
Schlundt J, Toyofuku H, Jansen J, Herbst SA. Emerging food-borne zoonoses. Revue Sci Technol. 2004;23(2):513–33.
Andargie G, Kassu A, Moges F, Tiruneh M, Huruy K. Prevalence of bacteria and intestinal parasites among food-handlers in Gondar Town, Northwest Ethiopia. J Health Popul Nutr. 2008;26:451–5.
Flint J, Duynhoven Y, Angulo F, Delong S, Braun P, Kirk M, Scallan E, Fitzgerald M, Adak G, Socket P, Elias A, Hall G, Gargour N, Wale H, Braam P. Estimating the burden of acute gastroenteritis, food-borne diseases and pathogens commonly transmitted by food. J Clin Infect Dis. 2005;41:698–704.
Latham MC. Human nutrition in tropical Africa. Rome: FAO; 1997. p. 329–437.
FAO. Street food: small entrepreneurs, big business; 1997. http://www.fao.org/News/1997/970408-e.htm. Accessed 24 Oct 2015.
Barro N, Bello AR, Aly S, Ouattara CMT, Iiboudo AJ, Traaore AS. Hygienic status assessment of dish washing waters, utensils, hands and pieces of money from street food processing sites in Ouagadougou (Burkina Faso). Afr J Biotechnol. 2006;5(11):1107–12.
Muinde OK, Kuria E. Hygienic and sanitary practices of vendors of street foods in Nairobi, Kenya. Afr J Food Agric Nutr Dev. 2005;5(1):1–13.
Nonga HE, Simforian E, Ndabikunze BK. Assessment of physicochemical characteristics and hygienic practices along the value chain of raw fruit juice vended in Dar es Salaam City, Tanzania. Tanz J Health Res. 2014;16(4):1–12.
FAO. Globalization of food systems in developing countries: impact on food security and nutrition. FAO Food and Nutrition Paper 83. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations Rome; 2004. http://www.fao.org/3/a-y5736e.pdf. Accessed 24 Oct 2015.
Viganò A, Pellissier N, Hamad HJ, Ame SA, Pontello M. Prevalence of E. coli, thermotolerant coliforms, Salmonella spp. and Vibrio spp. in ready-to-eat foods: Pemba Island, United Republic of Tanzania. Annal di igiene Medic Comun. 2007;19(5):395–403.
Simforian E, Nonga HE, Ndabikunze BK. Assessment of microbiological quality of raw fruit juice vended in Dar es Salaam City, Tanzania. Food Cont J. 2015;57:302–7.
Parekh TS, Subhash R. Molecular and bacteriological examination of milk from different milch animals with special reference to coliforms. Curr Res Bacteriol. 2008;1(2):56–63.
Gleeson D, O’Connell A, Jordan K. Review of potential sources and control of thermoduric bacteria in bulk-tank milk. Irish J Agric Food Res. 2013;52:217–27.
Shirima GM, Kazwala RR, Kambarage DM. Prevalence of bovine tuberculosis in cattle in different farming systems in the eastern zone of Tanzania. J Prev Vet Med. 2003;57:167–72.
Ryser ET. Public health concerns. In: Marth EH, Steele JL, editors. Applied dairy microbiology. New York: Mercel Dekker, Inc.; 1998. p. 263–403.
Hagstad HV, Hubbert WT. Food quality control: food of animal origin. 1st ed. Ames: Iowa State University Press; 1986. p. 156.
Jiddawi N.S. Marine fisheries. In: Ngusaru A, editor. Tanzania Coastal Management Partnership (TCMP). The present state of knowledge of marine science in Tanzania, synthesis report. Working Document 5047; 2001. pp. 64–99.
Ogutu-Ohwayo R, Hecky RE, Andrew S, Cohen AS, Les Kaufman L. Human impacts on the African Great Lakes. Environ Biol Fishes. 1997;50:117–31.
Huss H, Dalgaard P, Gram L. Microbiology of fish and fish products. In: Luten JB, Borresen T, Oihlenschlager J, editors. Seafood from producer to consumer, intergrated approach to quality. Development in food science 38. Proceedings of the international seafood conference on the occasion of the 25th anniversary of the WEFTA, held in Noordwijkerhout, The Netherlands, 13–16 Nov 1995; 1997.
Mhongole, OJM. Microbiology and spoilage trail in Nile Perch (Lates niloticus), Lake Victoria, Tanzania. Unpublished dissertation for Award of MSc. Degree at University of Iceland; 2009. pp. 1–85.
WHO. Food safety and food-borne illness. Factsheets of the Programmes and Projects of WHO. http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs399/en/. Accessed 24 Oct 2015.
Worku M. Bacteriological profile of locally prepared fresh fruit juices in Hawassa town, southern Ethiopia. Unpublished dissertation for Award of MSc. Degree in Medical Microbiology at Addis Ababa University Ethiopia; 2011. p. 55.
Olorunjuwon BO, Temitope BK, Muibat FO, Oluwadun A. Microbiological quality of some locally-produced fruit juices in Ogun State, South Western Nigeria. J Microbiol Res. 2014;2(1):001–8.
Zaika LL. The effect of temperature and low pH on survival of Shigella flexneri in broth. J Food Prot. 2001;64:1162–5.
Eribo B, Ashenafi M. Behavior of Escherichia coli O157:H7 in tomato and processed tomato products. Food Res Int. 2003;36:823–30.
Sivapalasingams S, Friedman CR, Cohen L, Tauxe RV. Fresh produce: a growing cause of outbreaks of food-borne illness in the United States. J Food Prot. 2004;67(10):2342–53.
Buck JW, Walcott RR, Beuchat LR. Recent trends in microbiological safety of fruits and vegetables. Plant Health Prog. 2003;. doi:10.1094/PHP-2003-0121-01-RV (online).
Penrose K, Castro MCD, Werema J, Ryan ET. Informal urban settlements and cholera risk in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. PLoS Neglec Trop Dis. 2010;4(3):631–5.
Kurwijila LR, Omore A, Staal S. Dairy sub sector development strategy, East Africa Regional initiatives in value chains. Lesson from on-going R & D initiatives in Dairy value chains, Rural Livelihood Development Company. Version Board 17 April 2009. https://eadd.wikispaces.com/file/view/RuralLivelihoodDevptCompanyDairyStrategy2009.PDF. Accessed 24 March 2012.
MAFSC (Ministry of Agriculture, Food Security and Cooperatives). Agriculture sector Review and Public Expenditure Review 2008/2009. United Republic of Tanzania; 2009. http://www.agriculture.go.tz/publications/english%20docs/Agricultutre%20Sector%20Review%20and%20Public%20Expenditure%20Review%20200809.pdf. Accessed 24 Oct 2015.
FAO. Recommended International Code of practice general principles of food hygiene (CAC/RCP 1-1969, Rev.4-2003); 2003. https://www.idfa.org/docs/default-source/resource-library/391_cxp_001e.pdf?sfvrsn=0. Accessed 24 Oct 2015.
Lore TA, Kurwijila LR, Omore A. Hygienic milk production. A training guide for farm-level workers and milk handlers in Eastern Africa. International Livestock Research Institute (ILRI), Nairobi; 2006. pp. 1–13.
ISO 7218:2007 (International Standards Organisation): Microbiology of food and animal feeding stuffs- general requirements and guidance for microbiological examination. No. 7218; 2007. pp. 8–15.
EAC (East African Community). East African Standard, raw cow milk specification; 2006. pp. 1–2.
TZS (Tanzania Bureau of Standards). Microbiology of food and animal feeding stuffs-method for enumeration of microorganisms—colony count technique at 30 °C. Tanzania Standards Specification No. 118; 2007.
ISO/FDIS. Milk and milk products—general guidance for the preparation of samples, initial suspensions and decimal dilutions for microbiological examination. International Organization for Standardization, Geneva, Switzerland. No. 8261 (E); 2001.
Hossain TJ, Alam MK, Sikdar D. Chemical and microbiological quality assessment of raw and processed liquid market milks of Bangladesh. J Food Sci Tech. 2011;5:6–17.
ISO 7251:2005 (International Standards Organization). Microbiology of food and animal feeding stuffs—horizontal method for the detection and enumeration of presumptive Escherichia coli—most probable number technique; 2006.
WHO. Guidelines for drinking-water quality. Surveillance and control of community supplies, vol 3, 2nd ed. WHO, Malta; 1997. p. 250.
CAC-GL 31-1999: Codex guidelines for the sensory evaluation of fish and shellfish in laboratories; 1999. p. 33. http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:6w68JYXUuFoJ:files.foodmate.com/2013/files_1771.html+&cd=9&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=tz. Accessed 24 Oct 2015.
Atabay HI, Corry JEL. The isolation and prevalence of campylobacters from dairy cattle using a variety of methods. J Appl Microbiol. 1998;84:733–40.
Karmali MA, Simor AE, Roscoe M. Evaluation of a blood free charcoal based selective medium for Campylobacter organisms from faeces. J Clin Microb. 1986;23:456–9.
On SLW. Identification methods for Campylobacters, Helicobacters and related organisms. Am Soc Microbiol J. 1996;9:405–22.
ISO 6579:2002 (International Standards Organization). Microbiology of food and animal feeding stuffs—horizontal method for the detection of Salmonella spp. 4th ed; 2002. p. 27.
EAS 217-1-3:2008. Microbiology of food and animal feeding stuffs—preparation of test samples, initial suspension and decimal dilutions for microbiological examination—part 1–3: specific rules for the preparation of meat and meat products. 1st ed; 2008. p. 26.
Standards Gulf. Microbiological Criteria for Foodstuffs—Part 1. Riyadh: GCC; 2000.
Tanzania Fisheries Act No. 22. The Fisheries Act, 2003 (No. 22 of 2003). Printed by the government printer, Dar es Salaam Tanzania; 2003. p. 144.
Bukuku JN, Nonga HE, Mtambo MMA. Assessment of raw milk quality and stakeholders awareness on milk-borne health risks in Arusha City and Meru District, Tanzania. Trop Anim Health Prod. 2015;47(5):927–32.
Kivaria FM, Noordhuizen JPTM, Kapaga AM. Evaluation of the hygienic quality and associated public health hazards of raw milk marketed by smallholder dairy producers in the Dar es Salaam Region, Tanzania. Trop Anim Health Prod. 2006;38:185–94.
Schoder D, Maichin A, Lema B, Laffa J. Microbiological quality of milk in Tanzania: from Maasai stable to African consumer table. J Food Prot. 2013;76(11):1908–15.
Kumar M, Agarwal D, Ghosh M, Ganguli A. Microbiological safety of street vended fruit chats in Patiala city. Indian J Med Microbiol. 2006;24(1):75–81.
Tambekar DH, Jaiswal VJ, Dhanorkar DV, Gulhane PB, Dudhane MN. Microbial quality and safety of street vended fruit juices: a case study of Amravati city. Int J Food Saf. 2009;10:72–6.
TBS (Tanzania Bureau of Standards). Ready to drink beverages (non-carbonated)—specification; 2003. http://www.tbs.go.tz/tbtdb/standards. Accessed 2 May 2013.
Moyo SJ, Maselle SY, Matee MI, Langeland N, Mylvaganam H. Identification of diarrheagenic Escherichia coli isolated from infants and children in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. BMC Infect Dis. 2007;90(7):1–7.
Lindblom GB, Ahren C, Changalucha J, Gabone R, Kaijser B, Nelsson LA, Sjogren E, Svennerholm AM, Temu M. Campylobacter jejuni/coli and enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli (ETEC) in faeces from children and adults in Tanzania. Scand Inf Dis. 1995;27:589–93.
Mdegela RH, Nonga HE, Ngowi HA, Kazwala RR. Prevalence of thermophilic Campylobacter infections in humans, chickens and crows in Morogoro, Tanzania. J Vet Med B. 2006;53:116–21.
Mdegela RH, Msuya-Bengesi C, Mbuthia P, Byarugaba D, Mtenga KJ, Kamundia PW, Tegule SS. Endocrine disruptors and microbial pathogens in Lake Victoria in the East African Region. In: Fisheries and aquaculture cluster Proceeding. Proceedings of the cluster workshop, Mwanza, Tanzania, 12–14 Dec 2010. pp. 112–123.
HEN developed the research proposal, collected data, compiled all data for raw milk, raw fruit juice and raw fish, analysed the data and drafted the manuscript. HAN planned the study, supervised data collection, participated in data analysis, interpretation and proof reading the final version of manuscript before submission. RHM was the overall supervisor in all activities involving study planning, data collection and he participated in providing scientific and technical advice in laboratory work and proof read the final version of manuscript before submission. EM participated in fruit juice sample collection, laboratory analysis and writing of report. GBN and JAM participated in raw fish sample collection physical and laboratory analysis, and writing of report. RW participated in raw milk sample collection, physical and laboratory analysis, and writing of report. All authors read and approved the final manuscript
The authors are indebted to the Tanzania Higher Students’ Loan Board for kindly financing this research. The cooperation showed by the dairy cattle farmers, milk vendors, fruit juice vendors and fish traders in Morogoro, and the entire laboratory staff in Department of Veterinary Medicine and Public Health, Sokoine University of Agriculture is highly appreciated.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.