Randomised clinical trial of an intensive intervention in the primary care setting of patients with high plasma fibrinogen in the primary prevention of cardiovascular disease
BMC Research Notes volume 5, Article number: 126 (2012)
We have studied the possible effects of an intensive lifestyle change program on plasma fibrinogen levels, in patients with no cardiovascular disease, with elevated levels of fibrinogen, normal cholesterol levels, and a moderate estimated risk of coronary heart disease (CHD) and we have also analysed whether the effect on fibrinogen is independent of the effect on lipids.
This clinical trial was controlled, unblinded and randomized, with parallel groups, done in 13 Basic Health Areas (BHA) in l'Hospitalet de Llobregat (Barcelona) and Barcelona city. The study included 436 patients, aged between 35 and 75 years, with no cardiovascular disease, elevated levels of fibrinogen (> 300 mg/dl), cholesterol < 250 mg/dl, 218 of whom received a more intensive intervention consisting of advice on lifestyle and treatment. The follow-up frequency of the intervention group was every 2 months. The other 218 patients followed their standard care in the BHAs. Fibrinogen, plasma cholesterol and other clinical biochemistry parameters were assessed.
The evaluation of the baseline characteristics of the patients showed that both groups were homogenous. Obesity and hypertension were the most prevalent risk factors. After 24 months of the study, statistically significant changes were seen between the adjusted means of the two groups, for the following parameters: fibrinogen, plasma cholesterol, systolic and diastolic blood pressure and body mass index.
Intensive intervention to achieve lifestyle changes has shown to be effective in reducing some of the estimated CHD factors. However, the effect of intensive intervention on plasma fibrinogen levels did not correlate with the variations in cholesterol.
This manuscript is a translation of our already published manuscript . Fibrinogen can be considered an independent cardiovascular risk factor (CVRF) [2, 3]. However, several studies have shown a correlation between cholesterol (CT) and fibrinogen levels . Also it has been argued that the elevated levels of fibrinogen may be influenced by environmental factors, diet, smoking, excess weight and physical exercise . Various clinical and epidemiological studies have described the implications of the elevated plasma fibrinogen values as CVRF in coronary, cerebral disease and peripheral arteries. The Northwick Park Heart study describes a relationship between high values of plasma fibrinogen and the risk of coronary ischemia . In REGICOR study , it was described as an average of fibrinogen of 2.92 g/l in males and 3.09 g/l in women, the plasmatic value of fibrinogen being highest in the subset of smoking patients. The study published by Gil et al. , described an intervention study done in a primary care setting, in patients with an average age of 72.6 years and with several CVRF; the prevalence of hyperfibrinogenemia was found to be 26.5%. Other studies in younger patients with an average age of 57 and clinical manifestations of cardiovascular disease, have found a prevalence of 60% [9, 10]. In different epidemiological studies, such as the Yano et al. , an increase in cardiovascular morbidity and mortality has been shown in patients with fibrinogen levels above 300 mg/dl.
Lifestyle interventions make a notable impact on some of the modifiable CVRF; in spite of this, there are not many studies who have analysed the effects of these modifications (smoking cessation, diet and physical exercise) on fibrinogen levels. In addition, these studies have been conducted in settings different from ours, and mostly at short term [5, 6]. Because of this, we have designed a study of intervention, in the primary care setting, to assess the effect on the fibrinogen levels in a subset of patients with intensive intervention (in frequency and intensity) on changes in their lifestyle, as compared to a control group, according to the usual intervention practiced in the basic areas of health (BHA). The study has been done in patients with fibrinogen levels > 300 mg/dl, total cholesterol < 250 mg/dl and an estimated moderate or high CHD risk according to Framingham , adjusted according to fibrinogen levels [12, 13] and had a follow up period of 2 years on each subject.
Primary aim To evaluate the effect of an intensive intervention to modify lifestyle (hypo caloric diet, smoking cessation and physical exercise) in the fibrinogen levels in patients without cardiovascular disease with hyperfibrinogenemia (> 300 mg/dl), total cholesterol levels less than 250 mg/dl and an estimated moderate or high CHD risk.
(a) To assess the effect of this intensive intervention in some of the modifiable Cardiovascular Risk Factors.
(b) To confirm that this effect is independent of the variations of the total cholesterol levels.
We designed a randomized, controlled clinical trial, parallel groups, consisting of 436 patients, divided into two groups: a) an intensive intervention group, both in the frequency and intensity of their changes in lifestyle, b) a control group, receiving the standard therapy. The protocol has been described in a previous publication . The study was approved by Jordi Gol I Gurina EECC.
- Patients of both genders, aged between 30 and 75 years, in which in two consecutive analyses, separated by a minimum interval of 15 days, with fibrinogen levels > 300 mg/dl and plasma total cholesterol < 250 mg/dl.
- Agreement to participate in the study, with written informed consent using procedures reviewed and approved by the EECC review board.
- Any lipid-lowering therapy (dietary or pharmacological intervention).
- Local or generalized infection, either acute or chronic.
- History of cardiovascular disease, according to medical records and/or anamnesis.
- Fibrinogen lowering therapies (ticlopidine, fibrates, pentoxifylline)
- Severe clinical pathology (terminally ill patients, dementia, etc.)
Sample size calculation
We have assumed that:
1. The prevalence of smoking, overweight, obesity and sedentarism in the study population are 28, 48 and 84% , respectively.
Giving Up Smoking Advice: 38%.
Dietary recommendations for overweight/obese patients: 20%.
Increase physical activity recommendations in sedentary patients: 30%.
3. Smoking cessation and regular physical activity (measured by means of one unit of sporting activity) reduces, on average, fibrinogen levels by 0.4 g/l, and a diet of 1,000-1,400 cal/day reduces mean fibrinogen from 3 to 2.8 g/l , during a complete follow up of one year.
Taking into account the prevalence of the cardiovascular risk factors described, the effectiveness of these interventions, its impact on fibrinogen levels and assuming an additive effect of all of them, we aim to achieve a mean reduction of fibrinogen of 17. 2 mg/dl, after a complete follow up of one year.
4. Intensive intervention will get an average reduction of fibrinogen levels twice as much as the standard one, i.e. a reduction of 34.4 mg/dl, during a follow up of one year.
5. An alpha risk of 5%, 80% (1-beta) power and that the standard deviation of fibrinogen is 55 mg/dl .
6. A percentage of 20% withdrawals.
Considering all these assumptions, the study was planned to include more than 436 patients.
Patients meeting the inclusion and exclusion criteria listed above were selected consecutively from those visited by the participating investigators.
Random allocation sequence
A blocked random allocation sequence was centrally generated by an statistician.
Blocks contained six participants, so that three of them will receive the usual intervention and three the intensive intervention. The order of assigned interventions within each block was randomised. When a investigator received the informed consent of a patient, he phoned a member of the research team, who assigned participants to the corresponding intervention.
Description of the groups
Control group. This subset of patients have received advice about their lifestyle (diet, exercise and smoking cessation) according to the practice guidelines of the 'Institut Català de la Salut'(ICS), following nernational consensus [12, 15].
Intervention group. An active follow up of this group of patients was done, consisting of:
- Phone calls to get psychologist support, and letters to record each visit with the physician, additional measures to encourage the maintenance of lifestyle modifications, which will be done every 2 months. In each visit, physical activity questionnaires were done, as well as both pharmacological medical recommendations and lifestyle changes [15–17]. A laboratory analysis was done every 8 months (Table 1).
Due to the nature of the study, patients and physicians allocated to the intervention group were aware of the allocated arm. However, outcome assessors and data analysts were kept blinded to the allocation.
Definitions and methods of measurement of outcome variables:
Administrative data: complete name, address and telephone number, name of the medical center of primary care, medical history, number of medical record, date of registration, date of birth and sex.
Toxic history: smoking habits (daily consumption of tobacco in number of cigarettes), alcohol consumption (g/day).
Pathological history: Arterial hypertension (HBP), diabetes mellitus (DM), dislipaemia, overweight/obesity, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.
Physical examination: weight (kg), size (cm), Body Mass Index (BMI) (kg/m2), Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) and Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP).
Physical activity: classification of the patient, according to the intensity of their physical activity: active, partially active or inactive.
Analytical data: Fibrinogen, Total cholesterol, High density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C) Low density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C), triglycerides, glucose, uric acid, Hematocrit (%), white blood cells and platelets.
Collection data and analysis: design of a data collection form, on which is listed data identification, variables of the study and the frequency of visits.
All patients provided written informed consent.
The initial characteristics of both groups have been compared by means of bivariate techniques: χ 2 test, in the case of proportions, and t Student test, in case of means. Analysis of Covariance was used to calculate the effect of the kind of intervention the final fibrinogen adjusted to the total cholesterol values.
To analyze the possible association between the type of intervention (dichotomous qualitative variable) and response variable (plasmatic fibrinogen levels, quantitative variable), Covariance analysis (ANCOVA) will be used. This statistical technique allows us to obtain 2 regression lines, parallel, that correlates the results of fibrinogen levels post intervention with the individual baseline, in each group of intervention, without a possible influence of the fibrinogen level values pre or post intervention between the 2 groups. This technique is also used to verify that the effect of the intervention in the final fibrinogen levels is independent of the final total cholesterol variations.
39 of the 624 patients at baseline decided not to participate, 19 were excluded because they did not meet inclusion criteria and 130 have an inappropriate laboratory analysis.
Of the remaining patients that met inclusion criteria, 438 were randomized and assigned to one of the 2 groups, and followed for a 2 year period. At the end of the 2 years, 72 were lost in the intensive intervention group, 64 in the standard intervention group, (Figure 1). The percentage of patients lost in the follow up was similar for the 2 groups.
Table 2 describes the initial baseline characteristics of the population assigned to each group. Both groups were homogenous, with neither statistically significant nor clinically relevant differences between them. The percentage of individuals who smoked was somewhat higher in the Group of intensive intervention (31.9%) as compared to the standard group (26.8%), while in this last group the number of diabetic patients is slightly larger (15.1% versus 11.9%).
Regarding the presence of cardiovascular risk factors, the prevalence of obesity and hypertension were, respectively, 55.5 and 41.4% in the standard group, and 46.8 and 42.7% in the intensive intervention group.
Table 3 shows the results of the analysis per protocol of the main outcomes of the study, according to the type of intervention, after a 2 year follow-up. When analyzing fibrinogen levels, we could find a difference 31.0 mg/dl between the mean adjusted fibrinogen levels, showing a statistically significant (p < 0.001) difference in favour of the intensive intervention. We could also see statistically significant differences in favour of intensive intervention between the adjusted final total cholesterol, SBP, DBP and BMI.
Table 4 shows the result of the 'per protocol evaluation' of 'tobacco consumption' variable according to the type of intervention. The difference in the proportion of smokers at the end the study is statistically significant as compared to the initial for each type of intervention, although we didn't find any significant differences between the proportions of smokers in groups at the end of the study.
Figure 2 shows the relationship between the fibrinogen levels and total cholesterol at the end of the study, according to type of intervention. The Covariance analysis done has not shown any statistically significant relationship between the fibrinogen levels and the total cholesterol at the end of the study.
Baseline demographics did not differ significantly between the 2 groups (Table 2).
The prevalence of some of the cardiovascular risk factors, such as hypertension, diabetes mellitus and smoking are similar to other population studies carried out in our environment [15, 18]. However, obesity, in our study, has shown a higher prevalence, possibly due to the characteristics of the population included: patients who visited their physician, mean average age of 57 years, and an estimated moderate or high cardiovascular risk, different from the usual care setting. These results confirms what other investigators have found in relation to obesity [19, 20], that it is becoming a major health problem, and desirable implement innovative strategies to prevent and treat it are urgently need.
The lifestyle modification- intensive intervention group, at the end of a 2 years of follow-up period, showed a significant reduction of the weight and BMI, as compared to the standard intervention group.
After 24 months of follow-up, we found a reduction statistically significant of total cholesterol, fibrinogen levels, SBP, DBP and BMI in the intensive intervention group, and showing no differences in other analyzed variables.
These results are similar to the ones found in a study done in 20 centers in a primary care setting in United Kingdom , which assessed the effectiveness of the motivational interview to modify the intake of fat, physical activity, SBP and DBP, as well as tobacco consumption in 883 patients with risk high cardiovascular disease. It was obtained a benefit in the intervention group, but these changes could not be neither controlled nor related to the changes achieved in fibrinogen levels.
It is well known that one of the tables used to calculate the estimated cardiovascular risk in primary prevention are tables of Framingham [22, 23]. Some authors  have proposed to adjust the obtained risk according to fibrinogen levels.
In our study, the fibrinogen levels values in the intensive- intervention group were decreased an average of 31 mg/dl. This would mean that, in the case of a male patient with a 330 mg/dl fibrinogen level, considered an estimated high risk calculated by adjusted Framingham tables by the plasma figures and received intensive intervention, could move to a moderate risk and, therefore, change the therapeutic goal.
In our study, intensive intervention of lifestyle modifications have been shown effective to reduce some major cardiovascular factors: Fibrinogen, total cholesterol, SBP, DBP and BMI. The effect of the intensive intervention in the fibrinogen plasma values is not correlated with variations the total cholesterol.
Lifestyle modification might play a role in reducing future cardiovascular events in healthy subjects with hyperfibrinogenemia.
Rodríguez Cristóbal JJ, Villaverde Grote CA, Flor Serra F, Travé Mercadé P, Pérez Santos JM, Peña Sendra E, en representación del grupo EFAP: Ensayo clínico de intervención en pacientes con hiperfibrinogenemia en prevención primaria de enfermedad cardiovascular en el ámbito de la atención primaria de salud. Clin Invet Arterioscl. 2008, 20: 102-9.
Ernst E, Resch KL: Fibrinogen as cardiovascular risk factor: a meta-analysis and review of the literature. Ann Intern Med. 1993, 118: 956-63.
Kannel WB: Overview of hemostatic factors involved in atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease. Lipid. 2005, 40: 1215-20. 10.1007/s11745-005-1488-8.
Dotevall A, Johansson S, Wilhelmsen L: Associaton between fibrinogen and other risk factor for cardiovascular disease in men and women. Results from the Goteborg MONICA survey 1985. Ann Epidemiol. 1994, 4: 369-74. 10.1016/1047-2797(94)90071-X.
Ernst E, Resch KL: Therapeutic interventions to lower plasma fibrinogen concentration. Eur Heart J. 1995, 16 (Suppl A): S47-53.
Danesh J, Collins R, Appleby P, Peto R: Association of fibrinogen, C-reactive protein, albumin, or leukocyte count with coronary heart disease: meta-analyses of prospective studies. JAMA. 1998, 279: 1477-82. 10.1001/jama.279.18.1477.
Masiá R, Pena A, Marrugat J, Sala J, Vila J, Pavesi M, Covas M, Aubó C, Elosua R: High prevalence of cardiovascular risk factors in Gerona, Spain, a province with low myocardial infarction incidence. REGICOR Investigators. J Epidemiol Community Health. 1998, 52: 707-15. 10.1136/jech.52.11.707.
Gil B, Avilés J, Maldonado A, Fernández M: Factores de riesgo en ancianos. Estudio de 143 cientes. An Med Intern (Madrid). 1997, 14: 495-9.
Rodríguez JJ, Villaverde CA, Torelló L, Trocho C, Tibau N, Villaverde AA: Relationship between cholesterol and fibrinogen in primary-care areas. 15 the Wonca World Conference. 1998, 78-
Rodríguez Cristóbal JJ, Villaverde Grote CA, Tibau Llardén N, Juan Babot O, Andrades Corrales A, Peña Sendra E: Relationship between cholesterol and fibrinogen in two populations of different geographical location of Catalonia. Rev Clin Esp. 2004, 204: 405-9. 10.1157/13064313.
Yano K, Grove J, Chen R, Rodríguez BL, Curb JD, Tracy RP: Plasma fibrinogen as a predictor of total and cause-specific mortality in elderly Japanese-American men. Arterio Throm Vascul Biol. 2001, 21: 1065-70. 10.1161/01.ATV.21.6.1065.
Wood D, De Backer G, Faergeman O, Graham I, Mancia G, Pyörälä K: Prevention of coronary heart disease in clinical practice. Summary of recommendations the second joint task force of European and other societies on coronary prevention. Blood Press. 1998, 5-6: 262-9.
Kannel WB: Influence of fibrinogen on cardiovascular disease. Drugs. 1997, 54 (Suppl 3): S32-40.
Rodríguez Cristóbal JJ, Benavides Márquez F, Villaverde Grote C, Peña Sendra E, Flor Serra F, Travé Mercadé P, EFAP Group: Randomised clinical trial of an intensive intervention into life-styles of patients with hyperfibrinogenaemia in primary prevention of cardiovascular pathology in primary health care. Aten Primaria. 2005, 35: 260-4. 10.1157/13072792.
Sociedad Española para el Estudio de la Obesidad (SEEDO): Consenso SEEDO'2000 para la evaluación del sobrepeso y la obesidad y el establecimiento de criterios de intervención terapéutica. Med Clin (Barc). 2000, 115: 587-597.
Maiques A, Villar F, Brotons C, Torcal J, Orozco-Beltran D, Navarro P, Lobos-Bejarano JM, Banegas B, Ortega S, Gil G, Solana S: Recomendaciones preventivas cardiovasculares en atención primaria. Grupo de expertos del PAPPS. Aten Primaria. 2007, 39 (Suppl 3): 15-26.
Woolf S, Jonas S, Lawrence R: Health Promotion and Disease Prevention in Clinical Practice. 1996, Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins, 177-223.
Medrano MJ, Cerrato E, Boix R, Delgado-Rodríguez M: Factores de riesgo cardiovascular en la población española: metaanálisis de estudios transversales. Med Clin (Barc). 2005, 124: 606-12. 10.1157/13074389.
Wadden TA, Berkowitz R, Womble LG, Sarwer DB, Phelan S, Cato RK, Hesson LA, Osei SY, Kaplan R, Stunkard AJ: Randomized trial of lifestyle modification and pharmacotherapy for obesity. N Engl J Med. 2005, 353: 2111-20. 10.1056/NEJMoa050156.
Shaw K, O'Rourke P, Del Mar C, Kenardy J: Intervenciones psicológicas para el sobrepeso o la obesidad (Revisión Cochrane). The Cochrane Library. 2005, [http://www.update-software.com]4
Steptoe A, Kerry S, Rink E, Hilton S: The impact of behavioral counseling on stage of change in fat intake, physical activity, and cigarette smoking in adults at increased risk of coronary heart disease. Am J Public Health. 2001, 91: 265-9.
Sans S, Fitzgerald AP, Royo D, Conroy R, Gram I: Calibración de la tabla SCORE de riesgo cardiovascular para España. Rev Esp Cardiol. 2007, 60: 476-85.
Marrugat J, Subirana I, Comín E, Cabezas C, Vila J, Elosua R, Nam BH, Ramos R, Sala J, Solanas P, Cordón F, Gené-Badia J, D'Agostino RB, VERIFICA Investigators: Validity of an adaptation of the Framingham cardiovascular risk function: the VERIFICA Study. J Epidemiol Community Health. 2007, 61: 40-7. 10.1136/jech.2005.038505.
Sources of funding were a grant from the FEA/SEA: 'Fundación y Sociedad Española de
Arteriosclerosis. Investigación clínico-epidemiológica. 2004'.
We thank all participating GPs for their cooperation, and Institut Català de la Salut, for the collaboration in the laboratory analysis. We also want to thank to the investigators participant in the EFAP trial:
ABS Florida Sud L'Hospitalet del Llobregat (Barcelona) Juan José Rodríguez Cristóbal, Lluís Gayolà Leuco, José M. Pérez Santos, Ana Aguilar Melgarejo, Francisca Rodríguez Cortés (pshcologist), Teresa González Nogales (nurse), Pere Noe Campderros (nurse), M. José González Burguillos (nurse), Ana Grande Froiz (nurse), Domingo Bleda Fernández, Elida Quillama Torres. Florida Nord L'Hospitalet del Llobregat (Barcelona) Raquel Adroer Martori, Luis Solsona Díaz, Antoni Vives Arguilagos, Nuria Sanfeliu Soto, Carmen Delgado Azuara, Celsa Fernández Álvarez (nurse), Elvira Zarza (nurse), Rosa Sorando Alastruey, Carmen Murillo Godoy (nurse). Unidad de trombosis y arteriosclerosis (CSIC), Carlos Alonso-Villaverde Grote, Esther Peña Sendra, Centre d'Investigació Cardiovascular (Institut Català de Ciències Cardiovasculars) Natalia Tibau Garden, Laboratorio de Análisis Clínicos. Pere Travé Mercadé Laboratorio de Análisis Clínicos.Centro de Atención Primaria Just Oliveras (L'Hospitalet del Llobregat) Centro de Atención Primaria Bon Pastor (Barcelona) Ramón Castelltort Escaler SAP (Servicio de Atención Primaria) L'Hospitalet del LlobregatMartí Julià (Cornellà - Barcelona) Cesar Asenjo Vázquez Sant Feliu de Llobregat-2 (Barcelona) Óscar Fariñas Balaguer, Sebastián Vignoli Carradori, Dolors Llovera Serentill, Jordi Colet Montserrat, Ana Boren Campillo (nurse), Ángeles Jiménez Sánchez (nurse) Bon Pastor (Barcelona) Roser Espona Barri Chafarinas (Barcelona) Montserrat Delgado de la Cruz, Montserrat Carmona (nurse) Río de Janeiro (Barcelona) Montserrat Rodríguez Mas, Pilar Martí de la Morera, Montserrat Alegret Fenoll (nurse), Francisca Benavides Márquez Santa Eulàlia Sud (L'Hospitalet del Llobregat Jordi Monedero Boada, M. Mar Forés Chacón, Rosa Viñas Vidal, [Barcelona]) M. Dolors Riera Cervera, Sònia Sarret Vilà Sant Martí (Barcelona) Ester Maroto Martínez Centre L'Hospitalet del Llobregat (Barcelona) Julia Solé López Les Hortes (Barcelona) Cristina González Viladecans 2 (Barna) Rosa Villafáfila Ferrero, José Luis Bravo, Adela Viniegra Domínguez, M. Carmen García Pulido, Marivi Vivo (nurse).
AML acts as a scientific advisor for Abbott Healthcare, SA. All other authors declare that they have no competing interest.
JJRC formulated the research question, designed the study and supervised its conduct together with CAV, PTM, and JMPS. CFP has done the statistical analysis of the EFAP research program. EPS has been working in the patients database. AML and DBF have been involved in the English version of the manuscript. All the authors approved the final manuscript.
About this article
Cite this article
José Rodríguez Cristóbal, J., Alonso-Villaverde Grote, C., Travé Mercadé, P. et al. Randomised clinical trial of an intensive intervention in the primary care setting of patients with high plasma fibrinogen in the primary prevention of cardiovascular disease. BMC Res Notes 5, 126 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1186/1756-0500-5-126